版權說明:本文檔由用戶提供并上傳,收益歸屬內容提供方,若內容存在侵權,請進行舉報或認領
文檔簡介
FLE>XTRONICSSMTdefect&countermeasure-level
I
SMT
缺陷及防范措施FLEXTRONICS·
Objective/
目的·SMTDefectsIdentification/SMT缺陷
確
定·Failureanalysismethodandprocedure/
缺陷分析的方法及流程
·SMTDefectsandCountermeasure/SMT缺陷及防范措施>Tombstoning/
立碑>Solder
Bridge/橋聯>ComponentDamaged
(Nicks,Cracks,orStressFractures)/元件損壞
>Misalignment/
偏位>ComponentLeadLifted
元件引腳翹高>SolderBall/
錫珠>Non-Wetting,Dewetting/虛焊,半潤濕>Cold
Solder/冷焊>Disturbed
Solder/焊錫紊亂>NoSolder/無錫>InsufficientSolder/
少錫>ExcessSolder/
多錫>WrongOrientation/Polarity/
反向,極性反>SolderHole/錫洞>Solder
Projections/錫尖>Others/其它FLEXTRONICSSlide
Contents2>
Know
the
common
defect了解常見缺陷類型
Analyzethepossiblecause分析可能的原因Countermeasureforthedefects基于以上原因采取的對策Objectives/目的FLEXTRONICS
3ldentify
the
SMT
defects
according
to
IPC-A-610
(Rev:D)根據
IPC-A-610(Rev:D)
確定缺陷.This
standard
is
a
collection
ofvisual
quality
acceptability
requirements
forelectronic
assemblies.IPC-A-610
是關于電子組裝外觀質量驗收條件要求的文件.ASSOCIATONCONNECTING。ELECTRONICS
INDUSTRIESFLEXTRONICS
4SMT
Defects
Identification/SMT缺陷確定Source:MPM'sA
user'sguidetomorepreciseSMT
printingFLEXTRONICS
5Major
Contributor
to
Defects/
缺陷的主要分布Incoming
Component
Failure
Analysis
缺陷分析FLEXTRONICS
6FailureAnalysis/缺陷分析WheretostartyourInvestigation-"Threesimple·Allthe
Products,allthe
time?所有的產品.任何時候?>Process
problem流程問題·Someofthe
products,someofthetime?部分產品,某些時候?>Process
or
Material
problem流程或物料問題·Someofthe
Products,allthetime?部分產品,任何時候?>Material
problem物料問題FLEXTRONICSi.e.,equipment,operator,etc.如:設備.作業(yè)員等questions”三個簡單問題7Two
Avenues
of
Investigation/
兩種調查途徑·
Historical
Research歷史記錄調查·
Tests
&Evaluations測試,評估FLEXTRONICS
8·Supplier
data供應商數據>Change
變
更Design
設計|
Material物料Process
流
程>Quality
tests?
品
質
測
試
?·Production
Records
生產記錄>Materialhandlingrecords物料記錄>New
batch
新批次>QAorInspection
reports/QA
或檢查記錄>Traceabilityreports&Validations
可追溯性報告
>SPC
data/SPC數據·
Environmental
Records環(huán)境記錄>Temp&Humidity
溫濕度>Power
電力>Maintenance
保養(yǎng)FLEXTRONICS"Historical
Research"
歷史記錄調查9Tests
&Investigations/
測試,調查·Inspection
檢
查>Visual
外觀>Chemical
化學>
Mechanical
機
械·
pe
ocess
if
possible
重復流程>Break
down
process
steps
細分流程
ed
op
l
隔離離物人料員>Functional
(parametric)功能(參變量)
>Materialsanalysis物料分析s隔nsratioateriaemIsolatIsolatedat
pr測
試etsResFLEXTRONICS
10·
Definethe
problem
precisely精確定義問題所在·ldentifytheprecisetimeoffirstoccurrence確定首次問題發(fā)生時間·Identifythosefactorswhicharecapableofcausingthe
problem確定可能導致問題的因素·
Don'twastetimeon
parameterswhichcannot
reasonably
impactthedefect不要在那些不是主導因素上浪費時間·
Investigatethosefactorssystematically系統的研究這些因素FLEXTRONICSFind
The
Root
Cause/
找到問題的根本原因11Factorsresult
inthedefects.Themany
interactionsshowthatthey
must
be
related
as
asystemandbere-evaluatedwhenchanges
occurs.FLEXTRONICS"Fish-bone"Chart/
魚骨圖Equipment設備
Methods方法Humidity濕度Temperature溫度Environment環(huán)境
Man
人Training培訓Authority認證Attitude態(tài)度Materials物料12Effective
Use
of
Background
Information/
有效利用信息·
Design
Data設計數據·
ConceptualAnalysis概念分析·
DOE's實驗設計FLEXTRONICS
13Control
to
guarantee
performanceFLEXTRONICS王
王nDF
ove
byfixingwhat'swrongDefinewhatsimportantasure
howwe'redoinglrre
what's
wrong3.donTty
FootCaucoPrapo
ced
CslulonemThe
DMAIC
Process/DMAIC
流程#a01GouE14SMT
Defects
and
CountermeasureSMT
缺
陷
及
防
范
措
施SMTDefects
and
Countermeasure/SMT缺陷及防范措施FLEXTRONICS
15
i
ents
standing
on
a
terminal
end片式元件末端翹起(墓碑)gonpnmbstop
comhitoCFLEXTRONICS
16Tombstoning/立碑Countermeasure/對策Mechanism:Surfacetension
incomponentterminal
isuneven
in
reflow.原理:在回流過程中零件兩末端的表面張力不均衡.1.Componentterminal
heatdistributedunevenly零件兩末端受熱分布不均衡.Insufficientsoaktime:Reflowprofileoptimization.保溫區(qū)時間太短:優(yōu)化回流曲線參數.2.PCB
Paddesign
issue(the
padsdistance
istoo
big):
DFM(DesignforManufacturability)to
improve
PCBpaddesign.PCB焊盤設計問題(焊盤間距太大):DFM以改善PCB焊
盤設計.Tombstoning/立
碑FLEXTRONICS17Tombstoning/
立
碑Countermeasure/對策3.Component
terminal
oxidization
or
contamination:Solderability
test
if
necessary
andRTVthedefect
material.元件末端氧化或者受污染:根據情況做可焊性實驗并且退還缺陷物料.4.Printingmisalignment:adjustprintingmachineparameters.絲印偏位:校正絲印機的參數.5.Placementmisalignment:Optimizethe
P&Pmachineparameters.貼片偏位:優(yōu)化貼片機的參數.6.Stencilaperturedesign
issue:studyand
improvetheaperturedesign.鋼網開孔的設計問題:研究并且改善開孔設計.FLEXTRONICS
18Solder
Bridge/
橋聯·A
solder
connection
across
conductors
that
was
joined.·
Solderhas
bridgedtoadjacent
non-commonconductoror
component.焊錫橋連到相鄰的非導體或元件.FLEXTRONICS
19焊錫在導體間非正常連接.Countermeasure/
對策1.Screenprintingissue/
絲印問題:a)Paste
height
out
of
UCL:Adjust
the
printer
to
control
the
paste
height.錫膏高度超出控制上線:校正絲印機,控制錫膏高度.b)Paste
printing
misalignmentor
bridging:Fine
tune
printing
machine./錫膏印刷偏位或者橋聯:優(yōu)化絲印機.c)Icicle
printing:Fine
tune
printing
machine
or
change
to
lowerviscosity
paste.絲印拉尖:優(yōu)化絲印機或者使用低粘性的錫膏.d)Solderpastecollapse:changetohigherviscositypaste./錫膏塌陷:使用高粘性的錫膏.e)Nonstandardstencilapertureopening:Studyandimprovetheaperture./不標準的鋼網開孔:研究并改善開孔.Solder
Bridge/
橋聯Pastecollapse錫膏塌陷FLEXTRONICSIcicle
printing
絲印拉尖Misalignment印刷偏位Bridging橋聯20Countermeasure/對策2.Pick
&Placement/貼片a)Componentplacingmisalignment:Finetunethe
P&Pmachine
.元件貼片偏位:優(yōu)化貼片機的參數.b)Highpressureforplacement:reducepressureto
propervalue
.貼片壓力過大:減少壓力到適當的參數.3.Wavesoldering/波峰焊a)Lowconveyorramp:Raisetheconveyorramp
peractualstatus.傳送帶角度過?。焊鶕嶋H情況加大傳送帶角度w
d
n
board:Increase
the
flux
spray
volume
on
board
before
going
through板上的助焊劑較少:波峰焊接之前加大助焊劑的噴射量goinxerflulsosseeLSolder
Bridge/
橋聯FLEXTRONICS21Component
Damaged(Nicks,Cracks,orStressFractures)/元件損壞Nicks,cracks,or缺
口
,
裂
紋
,
壓stress痕fractures.FLEXTRONICS22Countermeasurel對策1.Rawmaterialdamagedpurgethebatchmaterial/來料損壞:清除這批來料
rd
n
agn
n.(Fixture
or
machine
touch
it):Investigate
and
take
corectiveoperatioprocessdTdarSMsrinuoeonsamaa2在SMT
流程中損壞(夫具和設備接觸):調查分析并且對不規(guī)范的操作作出矯正行動3.Fast
cooling
rate
on
rerlow
process:Control
the
SMA
cooling
rate
to
below
4degree
per
second.在回流過程中冷卻速率過快:控制SMA
的冷卻速度使斜率保持在每秒4度以下Typicalreflowprofile/回流曲線典例:Component
Damaged(Nicks,Cracks,orStress
Fractures)/
元件損壞Reflowtime(s)FLEXTRONICS23FLEXTRONICS
24Misalignment/
偏
位Countermeasure/對策1.P&P
machine
function
unstable:Fine
tune
the
P&P
machine.貼片機性能不穩(wěn)定:優(yōu)化貼片機性能參數.a)FinetuneX,Ydata/
調整X,Y坐標b)Optimize
pick
and
placement
parameters./
校正吸料和貼片的參數.2.Component
termination
oxidization:Solderability
testif
necessary.Purge
the
failedmaterial/
元件末端氧化:可焊性實驗,清除不合格的來料.3.Operator
touch
the
component
prior
to
reflow:Standardize
the
operator
handling(documentcontrol)/
在回流爐前目檢操作員碰到貼片元件:標準化操作員操作(文件控制)Misalignment/
偏
位FLEXTRONICS25Component
Lead
Lifted
元件引腳翹高One
lead
orseries
of
leads
on
component
is
out
ofalignment
andfailstomakecontactwiththe
land.元件一個或多個引腳變形不能與焊盤正常接觸.dj
sintnotoirednoLeaursoJ-ase
pofhtmhnoogttiointformatTohuecbhWhenexaminingthe
toes
of
the
leaditcanbeobservedthatthese
have
liftedfromthecircuit
board.FLEXTRONICS26Component
Lead
Lifted/
元件引腳翹高Countermeasure/對策1.Component
lead
bent
before
placement:Sort
the
defective
part
and
return
it
to貼片前元件引腳變形:挑選出缺陷元件,退回供應商.2.Manual
placement
the
loose
part:Inspect
the
part
before
pass
it
to
reflow.手放散料:回流前目檢.FLEXTRONICS27vendor.Solder
Ball/
錫
珠·Solder
balls
are
spheres
ofsolderthat
remain
aftertheelectricalclearance.焊錫球是焊接后形成的呈球狀焊錫.·Solderfines
are
typically
small
balls
ofthe
original
solder焊錫殘渣是在回流中形成的小的球狀或不規(guī)則狀焊錫球.ld
z
l
lattered
around
thespssceeroavphwatohftreehesitngeneirurscnaioetctmnetensoacpsoldering
process.Solder
balls
violate
minimumFLEXTRONICS28Solder
beadingSolderbeadsbeneaththe
component
M.BleiseFLEXTRONICS
29Mid-Chip
Solder
ballingSolderballsunderthe
componentSolder
Ball/
錫
珠MoreVolume
of
solder
paste
printedSolder
paste
Solder
beadOccurrenceof
solderbead
(%)EKRALowLesspe**en
Te+nee2yHighCountermeasure/對策1.S
tencilAperturedo
notfocustopad:improvestencilapertureopening.
鋼網開孔沒有對準焊盤中心:改善鋼網開孔.2.Printingmisalignment:Finetuneprintmachine.絲印偏位:調整絲印機狀態(tài).3.Excess
paste:Cpk
control.多錫:Cpk
控制.4.Damp
PCB:Bake
the
PCB
before
loading
it
to
SMT.PCB焊盤受潮:
SMT
組裝流程之前烘烤PCB.6.Stencil
polluted:cleanthestencil.
鋼網臟污:清洗鋼網.7.Profile
ramp
up
is
too
fast:Optimize
reflow
profile.回流曲線升溫速度過快:優(yōu)化回流曲線.8.Pasteoxidized:exchangewithfreshsolderpaste.錫膏氧化:更換新錫膏.9.Chip
wave
or
solder
wave
height
is
too
high
caused
excess
solder
to
top
side:adjustthe
wave
soldering
height
to
proper
level
(wavesolder).波峰高度設置的太高致使多余的焊錫到頂面:校正波峰焊設置到適當的高度(波峰焊接).FLEXTRONICSSolder
Ball/
錫珠30·is
s
not
wetted
to
the
land
or
termination
where
solder虛焊:需要焊接的引腳焊盤不潤濕.·Solder
coverage
does
no
meet
requirements
for
the·Dewetting
as
a
condition
resultswhen
molten
solder
coats
asurface
and
then
recedes
to
leave
irregularly-shaped
mounds
d
of
solder
and
with
the
basis
metal
or
surface
finish
not半潤濕:熔化的焊錫浸潤表面后收縮,留下一焊錫薄層覆蓋部分
區(qū)域,焊錫形狀不規(guī)則.silofpnexthiedharrrequiSoldeNon-Wetting,Dewetting/虛焊,半潤濕ofsolderthat
areseparated
by
areasthat
are
covered
with
atermination
type.FLEXTRONICS31Non-Wetting,Dewetting/
虛焊,半潤濕1.Poor
solderability
of
component
or
pad./元件或焊盤可焊性太低Root
cause:a)Old
date
component
or
PCB./陳舊的元件或PCB
板b)Contamination
or
oxidation
on
component
or
PCB.
元件或焊盤污染或氧化Action:Purgethematerialforfurtherdisposition./清除來料2.The
paste
out
of
its
life
time:/錫膏超出有效期Scrapthe
lot
pasteand
replace
itwithfreshone報廢有問題的錫膏,更換新錫膏FLEXTRONICS
32Cold
Solder/
冷
焊·
Incomplete
reflowofsolderpaste.
焊錫回流不完全FLEXTRONICS
33Countermeasure/對策1.Peaktemperature
istoo
loworreflowtime(dwell回流峰值溫度太低或者回流時間不夠:重設溫度曲線圖
.Typical
reflowprofile:/
典型的回流曲線ColdSolder/冷焊time)is
not
enough:Re-setup
the
profile
to
fulfill
thepaste
spec
or
customer
provided
spec.requirement.ttt
廣CFLEXTRONICSmxmme(()34Time時間tc3
-large
SMD35tc1-small
SMDFLEXTRONICSToo
Hot!Too
Cold!Cold
Solder/
冷
焊Temp.
溫度250℃230℃tc1-medium
SMDCold
Solder/
冷
焊Countermeasure/對策2.The
component
in
some
location
covered
with
reflow
pallet
(Peak
temperature
istoo
low
or
reflow
time(dwell
time)is
not
enough):Enlarge
the
pallet
open
window
forthedefect
locationstoreducethe
△T.某些元件位置被回流托盤遮擋造成該點峰值溫度太低或回流時間不足:
對缺陷位置放大托盤的開口從而減少溫差(△T).FLEXTRONICS
36Disturbed
Solder/
焊錫素亂·Disturbedsolder
jointcharacterizedbystress
linesfrommovementin
the
connection.在冷卻時受外力影響,呈現紊亂痕跡的焊錫Countermeasure
/對策Check
and
adjust
the
cooling
airspeed
and
conveyor
status.檢測調整冷卻風速和傳送帶狀態(tài).
FLEXTRONICS37No
Solder/無錫No
soldertothe
land
orterminationwhere
solder
is
required.
焊點無錫FLEXTRONICS38Countermeasure/
對策1.Missingprinting/
漏印Root
cause:a)Stencil
aperture
was
jammed./鋼網堵孔b)Highviscosityofsolderpaste./
錫膏粘性過高Action:a)Cleanstencil;/清洗鋼網b)Replacethe
recycledpaste
with
fresh
one./更換新錫膏
c)Printing
machine
parameter
adjustment./校正絲印機參數2.Poor
solderability
of
component
or
pad./元件或焊盤可焊性太低
Root
cause:a)Old
date
component
or
PCB./陳舊元件或PCB板b)Contamination
on
component
or
PCB./元件或焊盤受污染
Action:Purge
the
material
for
further
disposition./清除來料3.Insufficient
flux
volume:increase
flux
spray
rate
(wave
solder).
助焊劑量不足:增加助焊劑噴射量(波峰焊接)4.Preheat
excess:lowerpreheat
temperature
properly(wave
solder).
預熱過度:適當降低預熱溫度(波峰焊)5.Chip
wave
or
solder
wave
height
is
low:proper
height
(wave
solder).
波峰高度過低:調整到適當高度(波峰焊)FLEXTRONICSNo
Solder/無
錫39Insufficient
Solder/
少錫Insufficientsolder焊錫不足FLEXTRONICS40Countermeasure
/對策1.Stencil
aperture
clogging
cause
incomplete
solder
printing):Automatic
or
manual
clean
the
stencil.鋼網孔堵塞導致錫膏不完全印刷:自動或者手工清洗鋼網
i
a
ti
l
dp
c
l
e(Paste
height
under
LCL):錫膏量不足(錫膏高度在LCL以下):目檢和Cpk
控制3.Solder
paste
misalignment:Fine
tune
printingmachine錫膏印刷偏位:校正絲印機使之最優(yōu)4.Poor
solderability
of
component
or
PCB
pad:
元件或PCB焊盤可焊性差
a)Optimize
reflow
profile.優(yōu)化回流曲線b)Exchange
the
poor
solderability
component.
更換掉低可焊性元件5.Excess
glue
or
glue
misalignment:Fine
tune
screen
(wave
solder).
點膠
過多或點膠偏位:優(yōu)化絲印參數6.Less
flux:Increase
the
flux
spray
on
board
before
it
pass
wave
soldering(wave
solder).助焊劑不足:增加助焊劑的噴射量olmtrunoovktepsCanooschegpusoinnleuosNV2.Insufficient
Solder/
少
錫FLEXTRONICS
41·Solderfillet
extends
ontothe
top
of
the
component
body.
焊錫接觸元件體.FLEXTRONICS42Excess
Solder/多錫Countermeasure/對策1.Excess
solder
paste:錫膏量過多a).Solder
paste
height
out
of
UCL:Adjust
printing
machine
to
control
the
paste
height.錫膏高度超出UCL:校正絲印機控制錫膏高度b).Nonstandard
of
stencil
aperture
opening:standardize
the
stencil
aperture
opening
fordifferenttypecomponents.鋼網開孔不標準:為不同類型的元件設置相應鋼網的開孔標準2.Wave
soldering/波峰焊接deag)a
nsvoel
i
3w~a5v
l
ring
time:Adjust
conveyor
ramp
angle
to
5~7傳送帶角度過小,波峰焊接時間變長:校正傳送帶角度到5~7度,焊接時間3~5秒b)High
preheat
temperature
to
dry
off
the
flux:According
to
flux
spec
to
control
the高預熱溫度造成助焊劑過度揮發(fā):按照助焊劑的規(guī)格控制預熱溫度,通常,PCB表面溫度
一般低于100℃FLEXTRONICSoocsseetnelomp,timganrrreencreeLowExcessSolder/多錫preheat
temperature,normally
the
PCB
surface
preheat
temperature
should
be
under100℃.43Wrong
Orientation/Polarity
反向,極性反Wrong
Polarity/極性反44CorrectPolarity/
正確的極性FLEXTRONICSWrong
Polarity:/極性反Anode
mark
onCorrect
Polarity/正確的極性Wrong
Polarity/
極性反Anode
mark
on
on
PCB.D503Cathode
mark
on
PCB.tantalum
capacitorCathode
mark
oncomponentbody.body.Wrong
Orientation/Polarity
反向,極性反WrongOrientation/反向:The
IC
is
populated
in
inversedirectiononthe
PCB.IC被反方向組裝在線路板上FLEXTRONICS
45WrongOrientation/反向Correctdirection/正確的方向IC
direction
markon
PCB.IC
direction
markon
the
device
body.PBU014Countermeasure/對策1.Wrongplacementmachineprogram:Checkand
correctthe
machine
program.貼片機程序錯誤:檢查和更正機器程序2.Manual
placement
in
reverse
direction:
手工放置元件錯誤a)Avoidmanualplacementcomponents
避免手工放置元件b)Need
special
inspection
for
the
manual
placement
prior
to
reflow(document
control).爐前需要特別檢查那些手工放置的元件(文件控制)3.Disorderedorientation
inthetray/reelofthe
incomingmaterial:卷裝或盤裝來料元件的不規(guī)則放置.a)Inspectbefore
loading
ittoSMT.上料前檢查來料b)Feedbacktovendortotakecorrectiveactions.反饋給供應商采取改善行動Wrong
Orlentation/Polarity
反向,極性反FLEXTRONICS46SolderHole/
錫洞·Blow
holes,pinholes,voids吹孔,針孔,空洞FLEXTRONICS47Countermeasure/
對策1.Insufficient
preheat:Reflow
profile
optimize.預熱時間不足:優(yōu)化回流曲線設置.2.Ramp
up
is
too
fast:Re-setup
the
reflow
profile
to
make
it
optimize.
升溫速率太快:重設回流曲線圖使之最優(yōu)化.3.Excessfluxinsolderpaste:properlytoincrease
preheat
time
and
temperature.錫膏助焊劑含量過多:適當增加預熱時間和溫度值.4.Damp
PCB:Bakethe
PCBbefore
loading
ittoSMT.PCB受潮:SMT
組裝前烘烤PCB板.5.Co
mponentfeetoxidation:Bake
itbeforeSMTorrequirevacuum
packing
on
incomingmaterial.元件腳氧
溫馨提示
- 1. 本站所有資源如無特殊說明,都需要本地電腦安裝OFFICE2007和PDF閱讀器。圖紙軟件為CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.壓縮文件請下載最新的WinRAR軟件解壓。
- 2. 本站的文檔不包含任何第三方提供的附件圖紙等,如果需要附件,請聯系上傳者。文件的所有權益歸上傳用戶所有。
- 3. 本站RAR壓縮包中若帶圖紙,網頁內容里面會有圖紙預覽,若沒有圖紙預覽就沒有圖紙。
- 4. 未經權益所有人同意不得將文件中的內容挪作商業(yè)或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文庫網僅提供信息存儲空間,僅對用戶上傳內容的表現方式做保護處理,對用戶上傳分享的文檔內容本身不做任何修改或編輯,并不能對任何下載內容負責。
- 6. 下載文件中如有侵權或不適當內容,請與我們聯系,我們立即糾正。
- 7. 本站不保證下載資源的準確性、安全性和完整性, 同時也不承擔用戶因使用這些下載資源對自己和他人造成任何形式的傷害或損失。
最新文檔
- 2025年湘教新版第二冊生物下冊月考試卷
- 2025年外研版三年級起點選擇性必修3歷史上冊階段測試試卷
- 2025年粵教新版七年級生物下冊月考試卷
- 2025年度農貿場農產品質量檢測中心建設合同4篇
- 2025年金融衍生品交易總合同2篇
- 2025年度牛只運輸車輛GPS定位與實時監(jiān)控服務合同4篇
- 2025版人工智能語音助手定制開發(fā)合同4篇
- 房屋出租委托代理合同(2篇)
- 2025年度學校教室窗簾更換項目承包合同4篇
- 二零二五版人工智能教育平臺合作合并合同2篇
- 2024版塑料購銷合同范本買賣
- 2024-2025學年人教新版高二(上)英語寒假作業(yè)(五)
- JJF 2184-2025電子計價秤型式評價大綱(試行)
- GB/T 44890-2024行政許可工作規(guī)范
- 2024年安徽省中考數學試卷含答案
- 2025屆山東省德州市物理高三第一學期期末調研模擬試題含解析
- 2024年滬教版一年級上學期語文期末復習習題
- 兩人退股協議書范文合伙人簽字
- 2024版【人教精通版】小學英語六年級下冊全冊教案
- 汽車噴漆勞務外包合同范本
- 微項目 探討如何利用工業(yè)廢氣中的二氧化碳合成甲醇-2025年高考化學選擇性必修第一冊(魯科版)
評論
0/150
提交評論