




已閱讀5頁(yè),還剩69頁(yè)未讀, 繼續(xù)免費(fèi)閱讀
版權(quán)說(shuō)明:本文檔由用戶提供并上傳,收益歸屬內(nèi)容提供方,若內(nèi)容存在侵權(quán),請(qǐng)進(jìn)行舉報(bào)或認(rèn)領(lǐng)
文檔簡(jiǎn)介
,Refutation,What,How,Example,Refutationisthepartofanargumentwhereinaspeakerorwriteranticipatesandcountersopposingpointsofview.,InformallogicAnobjection(alsocalledexpostulationorrefutation),isareasonarguingagainstpremise,lemma,ormaincontention.,Greco-Romans,Truthdoesnotfearcontention.Themorethetruthisdebated,thecleareritbecomes.,PlatoAsummaryoftheargumentyouarerefuting;Anacknowledgeofthestrengthsoftheargument,ifany;Theaspectsoftheargumentthatyoubelieveareflawed;,Howto,WriteIntroduction,Howto,WriteIntroduction,2.BecharmingYoucanwintheattentionandgoodwillofyourreadersbytellinganinterestingstory,quotingagoodcommentontheissue.Youshouldavoidpomposity,andshowconcernforyourreaders.Youshouldpresentyourselfasfair-mindedandgood-natured.,HowtowriteIntroduction,HowtowriteBody,HowtowriteConclusion,Howwe,writeRefutation,Whatopposingargumentscanbeattacked,Threetypesoforganization,Fourstepsinrefutation,Languageofrefutation,Howto,Writebody,Argumentsaretheresultofreasoningaboutevidence,Attacksonevidence,Attacksonreasoning,Attacksonclaims,Twobroadtestsofevidenceare:Istheevidencecorrect?Istheevidenceadequatetoprovetheargument?,AttacksOnevidence,ThenextMoreparticularcriteriafortestingevidence,22,So-calledAuthorityleansonthepopularityofsomeonewhomayhavelittleknowledgeoftheissueorproduct.Example:CNNsLouDobbs,regularlyusesafigureof20millionwhendiscussingthenumberofillegalaliensonhisbroadcastLouDobbsTonight.“However,thePEWCenter,amoreobjectivesourceplacesthenumberat11million.,AttacksOnevidence,23,Flawedstatisticaldatasmallsampleandspecialsample;thetotalnumberofsamplesisunknown;Example:Therewere13gun-relatedfatalitiesamongchildreneveryday,butdidnttelltheexactagerange.,AttacksOnevidence,24,Ignorethechangeofconditionswithoutconsideringthechangeoftime,spaceandotherexternalconditionswhichmayleadtothealterationofevidence.Example:ConventionalweaponscausedmuchmoredamageinworldWarIIthanatomicweapons,soconventionalweaponsaremorelethal.However,itsundertwodifferentcircumstances.,AttacksOnevidence,25,SuppressedevidencehidesomeaspectswhichisagainsttheclaimExample:Anadvertisementclaimsaparticularcarhasmorehorsepowerand0-60speed,butfailstomentionitalsodoesworseincrashtests,andhasworsereliability.,AttacksOnevidence,26,Self-contradictoryevidenceIfyousayorwritesomethingthatisself-contradictory,youmaketwostatementswhichcannotbothbetrue.Example:BushhasblockedprescriptiondrugimportsfromCanadaoversafetyconcerns,buthealsosaidtheU.S.couldrelyonCanadaformorefluvaccine.,AttacksOnevidence,27,Negativeevidencetheevidenceisnotrightormoralinacivilizedsociety,isevil-minded,immatureviciousorharmful,issexistordiscriminatory,orculturallyunacceptable.Example:ItsnotnecessarytoabolishdeathpenaltyinChinabecausethepopulationofChinaissolarge.However,itsevil!,AttacksOnevidence,28,AtypicalevidencetheevidenceisnottypicaltoprovetheclaimExample:Anadforamiracledietofferstestimonialsasproof,butfailstoprovideacontrolledclinicalstudytoprovethedietreallyworks.,AttacksOnevidence,29,Argumentsaretheresultofreasoningaboutevidence,Attacksonevidence,Attacksonreasoning,Attacksonclaims,HastygeneralizationsArrivingataconclusionwithoutenoughevidence.Example:LiHuaandWangPing,whoaretwoAsian-Americanstudents,dowellinmath,soallAsian-Americanstudentsarebetterinmath.,AttacksOnreasoning,31,BandwagonThinkingClaimingthatmostpeopleagreesoitmustberight.Example:ItswidelyacceptedthatFrenchpeoplearemoreromantic,soFrenchmustberomantic.,AttacksOnreasoning,32,Singlecause-effectClaimingthatonlyoneeventcausedanother.Example:WhenIsatdownatthecomputeritstoppedworking,soImusthavedonesomethingwrong.,AttacksOnreasoning,33,NoconnectionThecausedoesnotrelatetotheeffect.Example:LetsnottakeXiaoJingtengonourpicnic.Everytimewetakehimoutwithus,itrains.,AttacksOnreasoning,34,Either/OrSuggestingonlytwoalternativeswhiletheissuemaybemuchmorecomplex.Example:Bush:“eitheryoureforAmericaoryourefortheterrorists”,AttacksOnreasoning,35,CircularReasoningRestatingindifferentwordswhathasalreadybeenstated.Example:Xiaomingisabachelorbecausehehasntgotmarried.,AttacksOnreasoning,36,FalseAnalogyTheargumentassertsthatiffactsrelatingtoAandfactsrelatingtoBarealikeinsomeessentialrespects,theywillbealikeinanother,orother,essentialrespects.Example:Studentsshouldbeallowedtolookattheirtextbooksduringexaminations.Afterall,surgeonshaveX-raystoguidethemduringanoperation,lawyershavebriefstoguidethemduringatrial,carpentershaveblueprintstoguidethemwhentheyarebuildingahouse.,AttacksOnreasoning,37,1.Sequentialattack(argument1-argument2-argument3),Whatopposingargumentscanbeattacked,Threetypesoforganization,Fourstepsinrefutation,Languageofrefutation,Howwe,Writebody,38,2.Primaryandsecondaryattacks,Threetypesoforganization,Howwe,Writebody,refutationofprimaryargumentrefutationofsecondaryargument,3.Concessiontypeattack,TomakethebodypartcoherentandconsistentRebuttalofAisnotnecessarilytobethefirst,butitscriticaltofindoutthelogicalconnectioninthewholeoriginalarticletoberefuted,40,VideoExamplesVideo1Video2,Threetypesoforganization,41,1.Theargumenttoberefutedanditsrelationshiptothecaseasawhole.,Howwe,Writebody,Example:Indevelopinganeedforpricecontrols,theeffectofinflationhasbeeninjurioustothewelfareoftheAmericanlaborer.Now,ifthisweretrue,theaffirmativewouldindeedhaveastrongargument.,Whatopposingargumentscanbeattacked,Threetypesoforganization,Fourstepsinrefutation,Languageofrefutation,42,2.Statehowyouwillrefutetheargument.,Example:However,itcanbedemonstratedthattheaffirmativehasreachedanerroneousconclusionbyneglectingthemostrelevantaspectsoftheUnitedStateseconomicpicture.,43,3.Refutationwithsupportingevidence.,Example:HastheUnitedStateslaborerbeenhurtbyinflation?Onthecontrary,accordingtotheSecretaryoftheTreasury,hisbuyingpowerhasgoneupfortypercentinthepasttwentyyears,andaccordingtoastudyconductedbythelabororganizationsthemselves(AFL-CIOreport),“Thelaborer,eventhoughpriceshavegoneup,stillisinapositiontobuymoreofthedesiredgoodsonthemarketthaneverbefore.”,44,4.Theeffectoftherefutationandtransitiontocontinuedrefutation.,Example:Thusweseethattheaffirmativeneedargument,anappealtothewelfareoflabor,isrefutedbythelaborleadersthemselves.Now,letusproceedtotheirotherneedargumentstoseeiftheyarerealorlargelyimaginary.,45,Makethemeansofcommunication-language-asclearaspossible.AvoidvaguetermsUsethevocabularyofdebatebyreferringtoissues,arguments,andevidence.,Howwe,Writebody,Whatopposingargumentscanbeattacked,Threetypesoforganization,Fourstepsinrefutation,Languageofrefutation,46,【Avoid】Thepointhasbeenbroughtup.【Because】Vague.Callingeverythingapoint,whetheritisanissue,andargument,orevidence,isprobablythemostcommonlanguageerrorindebate.Byitselfitisvague;whenitisoveruseditleadstototalconfusion.【Useinstead】“Thecontentionofworkabilityhasbeenattackedwiththeargumentthat”,【Avoid】“Asourquoteshaveproved”【Because】Vague.Beconcretebymakingspecificreferences.【Useinstead】“Ontheotherhand,bothProfessorX,ofWhiteUniversity,andtheDirectoroftheNationalScienceFoundationhaveproved”,【Avoid】“Theysaid”or“Wesaid”【Because】Vagueandclumsy.【Useinstead】“Thefirstaffirmativespeakerasserted”or“MissSmith,inherfirstconstructivespeech”,【Avoid】“Westandon”【Because】Clumsy.【Useinstead】“Oursupportofthiscontentionhasbeen”,【Avoid】“Whereistheirproof?”and“Wehaveofferedproof.”【Because】Clumsyanderroneous.Proofisoftenconfusedwithevidence.【Useinstead】“Whereisthesupportingevidencetoprove”and“Wehaveofferedevidencetosupport”,Bonus!,Typicallanguageusedinrefutation,Althoughitiscommonlyheldthatsuccesswillbringpeoplemoneyandstatus,itisunlikelytobetruethatitwillbeadesirablegoalforanyone.Consideringthegreatstresstheyhavetolivewith,andtheirshorterlifespans,greaterloneliness,andrelativeincapacityforcommunityorloveitentails,itisconceivablethatnoteveryonefindsanenterpriserequiringsuchsacrificeisworthwhatitcosts.雖然大多數(shù)人認(rèn)為成功能給人帶來(lái)金錢和地位,但是每個(gè)人都渴望成功卻不一定是事實(shí)。想一想為了成功所要承受的緊張壓力,壽命的可能縮短,巨大的孤獨(dú),不能有常人的感情交流和愛(ài)情??梢韵胂?,不是所有的人都認(rèn)為為追求一個(gè)目標(biāo)付出這么多的犧牲是值得的,Itisprobablytruethatinstitutingsanctionsmaysignificantlyreducethefrequencyofwrongspeechesoncampus,butonevitalpointisbeingleftoutofourthinking:thesemeasuresposeaseriousthreattotheveryideaoftheuniversityandthespiritofacademicfreedom.采取制裁措施可能會(huì)顯著地減少校園的“錯(cuò)誤”言論,但是有一點(diǎn)我們沒(méi)有考慮進(jìn)去:這些措施對(duì)大學(xué)的本身宗旨以及學(xué)術(shù)自由精神構(gòu)成了威脅。,Typicallanguageusedinrefutation,Onthesurface,thecommentsmadebymenaboutwomensabilitiesseemreasonable.Butoncloseexamination,thecommentsrevealtherealcontemptthatmenfeelforwomenandthebasichostilitythatmenhavetowardwomen.表面上,男人對(duì)婦女的能力所作的評(píng)論似乎有點(diǎn)道理,但仔細(xì)檢查一下,這個(gè)評(píng)論反映了男人對(duì)婦女的真正蔑視和對(duì)婦女的態(tài)度基本上是對(duì)立的。,Typicallanguageusedinrefutation,Somepeoplesuggestthatamanagerorahighexecutivecanspeakwellandlogicallybecauseoftheopportunitiesofhisposition.Thatisputtingthecartbeforethehorse.Moreoftenthannot,quitethereverseistrue.Itishisskillinwordsthathelpshimtogethisjob.Thatis,ifyouconsciouslyincreaseyourvocabularyyouwillunconsciouslyraiseyourselftoamoreimportantstationinlife.Ofcourse,thenewandhigherpositionyouhavewonwill,inturn,giveyouabetteropportunityforfurtherenrichingyourlanguage.Itisabeautifulandsuccessfulcycle.有的人說(shuō)一個(gè)經(jīng)理或一個(gè)高級(jí)管理人員之所以口才好,講話有邏輯是因?yàn)樗穆毼唤o他創(chuàng)造了這樣的條件。這就有點(diǎn)本末倒置了。許多情況下,事實(shí)正好相反。他的詞語(yǔ)能力正好幫助他獲得了他的這個(gè)職位。也就是說(shuō)如果你注意擴(kuò)大你的詞匯,你就會(huì)在無(wú)意中提高生活中的地位。當(dāng)然你得到的一個(gè)新的更重要的職位會(huì)反過(guò)來(lái)為你進(jìn)一步豐富你的語(yǔ)言創(chuàng)造好的條件。這是一個(gè)良性的成功的循環(huán)。,Typicallanguageusedinrefutation,HowtowriteIntroduction,HowtowriteBody,HowtowriteConclusion,Howwe,writeRefutation,Howto,writeconclusion,4.Statisticalfindings:datashowinghowmuch,howmany,orhowoftencanbeconvincing.5.Personalexperiencesorobservations:Sometimestheycandeliveranargumentativemessagemoreforcefullythananyotherkindofevidence.Personalexperienceusuallyreinforcesbutdoesnotreplaceotherkindsofevidences.,HowtoendRestartyourthesisindifferentwaysLookintothefutureMakefunofyouropponentsSummarizeyourmajorpointsifyourpaperislong,HowtowriteconclusionRestateyourthesisindifferentwaysLookintothefutureMakefunofyouropponentsSummarizeyourmajorpointsifyourpaperislong,TipsforYourEssay,DontmakeupevidenceCiteyoursourcesMakeanoutline,AvoidemotionallanguageKnowthedifferencebetweenalogicalconclusionandanemotionalpointofview,What,How,Example,Toomuch,Concepts!,Istrike!,P,P,T,61,Asampleessay,so,Thenextoneis,Natureexamineswhetherandhowanathletesperformancehistoryandthelimitsofhumanphysiologycouldbeusedtocatchdopers.,sampleessay,Yesperformancewasanomalous(異常)withanimprovementabout7seconds(6.72s).Acleandrugtestduringcompetitioncouldnotruleoutthepossibilityofdoping(興奮劑).Performancecouldbeusedtonabdopers.Anathletewillbedisciplinedsimplyforperformingtoowell.,OUTLINEOFREFUTATION,IntroductionBody1.Refute:thedataof“7seconds”2.Refute:“anomalous”improvement3.Refute:compareRyanLochteslast50metrestoYes4.Refute:anotherexampleofcherry-picking5.Refute:adrugtestcannotruleoutthepossibilityofdoping6.Refute:Callawayfailedtomentionout-of-competitiondrugtestConclusion,IntroductionpartFROMLAIJIANG,DepartmentofChemistry,UniversityofPennsylvania,ItisashametoseeNaturewhichnearlyallscientists,includingmyself,regardasoneofthemostprestigiousandinfluentialphysical-sciencemagazinespublishathinlyveiledbiasedarticlelikethis.Granted,thisisnotapeer-reviewedscientificarticleanddidnotgothroughthescrutinyofpickingreferees.Buttoserveasachannelforthegeneralpopulacetobeintouchwithandappreciatescience,theauthorsandeditorsshouldatleastpresentthereaderswithfactswithinthepropercontext,whichtheyblatantlyfailedtodo.,Background/Hook,Bodypart,First,toidentifyYesperformanceincrease,EwenCallawaycomparedherOlympic400-metreIMtimewithherperformanceattheWorldChampionshipsin2011(4:28.43and4:35.15,respectively)andconcludedthatshehadan“anomalous”improvementofaround7seconds(6.72s).Infact,herpreviouspersonalbestwas4:33.79attheAsianGamesin2010.Thisleadstoanimprovementof5.38seconds.Inasportingeventinwhich0.1scanbethedifferencebetweenthegoldandsilvermedal,Iseenoreasonfor5.38stobetreatedas7s.,Reviewthewrongfacts,Listfacts,Yourargument,Effectofyourrefutationonopponentscase,p1,Bodypart,Second,aspreviouslypointedout,Yeisonly16yearsoldandherbodyisstilldeveloping.Betteringoneselfby5secondsovertwoyearsmayseemimpossibleforanadultswimmer,butitcertainlyhappensamongyoungsters.AninterviewwithAustraliangoldmedallistIanThorperevealedthathis400-metrefreestyletimeimprovedby5secondsbetweentheagesof15and16.Forregularpeople,includingCallaway,itmaybehardtoimaginewhataneliteswimmercanachieveasheorshematuresandundergoesscientificandpersistenttraining.Butjumpingtotheconclusionthatitis“anomalous”basedonOhthatssotoughIcannotimagineitisrealishardlysound.,Listfacts,Yourargument,Effectofyourrefutationonopponentscase,p2,Bodypart,Third,tocompareRyanLochteslast50metrestoYesisatextbookexampleofcherry-pickingyourdata.Yes,LochtewasslowerthanYeinthelast50metres,butLochtehadahugeleadinthefirst300metres,sohechosenottopushhimselftoohardandtoconservehisenergyforlater.Ye,ontheotherhand,wastrailingbehindafterthefirst300metresandreliedonfreestyle,inwhichshehasanedge,towintherace.Failingtomentionthisstrategicdifference,aswellasthefactthatLochteis23.25secondsfaster(4:05.18)thanYeoverall,createstheillusionthatawomanswamfasterthanthebestmaninthesamesport,whichsoundsimpossible.Puttingasidethegenderargument,Ibelievethisisstillaleadingquestionthatimpliestothereaderthatthereissomethingfishygoingon.,cherry-picking,Listfacts,Yourargument,Effectofyourrefutationonopponentscase,p3,Bodypart,Fourthisanotherexampleofcherry-picking.Inthesameevent,therearefourmaleswimmerswhoswamfasterthanbothLochter(29.10s)andYe(28.93s)inthefinal50metres:KosukeHagino(28.52s),MichaelPhelps(28.44s),YuyaHorihata(27.87s)andThomasFraser-Holmes(28.35s).Asitturnsout,ifwearejusttalkingaboutthelast50metresina400-metreIM,LochterisnottheexampleIwouldhaveusedifIweretheauthor.WhatkindofscientificrigorousnessisCallawaytryingtodemonstratehere?IsitlogicalthatifLochteristhechampion,weshouldassumethatheleadsineverysplit?Thatwouldbeaterriblewaytoteachthepublichowscienceworks.,cherry-picking,Listfacts,Yourargument,Effectofyourrefutationonopponentscase,p4,Bodypart,FifthistheissueIopposethemost.CallawayquotesRossTuckerandimpliesthatadrugtestcannotruleoutthepossibilityofdoping.Anyonewhohastakenquantum101willtellyouthateverythingisprobabilisticinnature,andsothereisaprobabilitythatthedruginanathletessystemcouldtunneloutrightatthemomentofthetest.Aslightchanceitmaybe,butshouldwedisregardalltestresultsbecauseofit?Letsbepracti
溫馨提示
- 1. 本站所有資源如無(wú)特殊說(shuō)明,都需要本地電腦安裝OFFICE2007和PDF閱讀器。圖紙軟件為CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.壓縮文件請(qǐng)下載最新的WinRAR軟件解壓。
- 2. 本站的文檔不包含任何第三方提供的附件圖紙等,如果需要附件,請(qǐng)聯(lián)系上傳者。文件的所有權(quán)益歸上傳用戶所有。
- 3. 本站RAR壓縮包中若帶圖紙,網(wǎng)頁(yè)內(nèi)容里面會(huì)有圖紙預(yù)覽,若沒(méi)有圖紙預(yù)覽就沒(méi)有圖紙。
- 4. 未經(jīng)權(quán)益所有人同意不得將文件中的內(nèi)容挪作商業(yè)或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文庫(kù)網(wǎng)僅提供信息存儲(chǔ)空間,僅對(duì)用戶上傳內(nèi)容的表現(xiàn)方式做保護(hù)處理,對(duì)用戶上傳分享的文檔內(nèi)容本身不做任何修改或編輯,并不能對(duì)任何下載內(nèi)容負(fù)責(zé)。
- 6. 下載文件中如有侵權(quán)或不適當(dāng)內(nèi)容,請(qǐng)與我們聯(lián)系,我們立即糾正。
- 7. 本站不保證下載資源的準(zhǔn)確性、安全性和完整性, 同時(shí)也不承擔(dān)用戶因使用這些下載資源對(duì)自己和他人造成任何形式的傷害或損失。
最新文檔
- 2025年數(shù)據(jù)軟件協(xié)議手冊(cè)
- 2025年倉(cāng)儲(chǔ)管理策劃與物流合作協(xié)議
- 2025年企業(yè)策劃與市場(chǎng)營(yíng)銷宣傳戰(zhàn)略協(xié)議
- 2025臨時(shí)工作合同(合同范本)
- 醫(yī)學(xué)人文教育對(duì)臨床技能提升的促進(jìn)作用
- 小麥抗白粉病育種的多元化育種策略
- 運(yùn)動(dòng)驅(qū)動(dòng)健康生活
- 打造餐飲卓越服務(wù)
- 2025年土地經(jīng)營(yíng)權(quán)流轉(zhuǎn)合同新范文
- 高中生健康教育指南
- ISOIEC38507-2022信息技術(shù)-IT治理-組織使用人工智能的治理影響(中文版-雷澤佳譯2024)
- 2024年西北工業(yè)大學(xué)附中丘成桐少年班初試數(shù)學(xué)試題真題(含答案詳解)
- 全過(guò)程工程咨詢投標(biāo)方案(技術(shù)方案)
- 初中物理神奇的電磁波+物理教科版九年級(jí)下冊(cè)
- GB/T 718-2024鑄造用生鐵
- 2024-2029年中國(guó)無(wú)溶劑復(fù)合機(jī)行業(yè)市場(chǎng)現(xiàn)狀分析及競(jìng)爭(zhēng)格局與投資發(fā)展研究報(bào)告
- 汽車維修項(xiàng)目實(shí)施方案
- 競(jìng)技體育人才隊(duì)伍建設(shè)方案
- 《多聯(lián)機(jī)空調(diào)系統(tǒng)工程技術(shù)規(guī)程》JGJ174-2024
- MOOC 微積分(二)-浙江大學(xué) 中國(guó)大學(xué)慕課答案
- 跨學(xué)科學(xué)習(xí):一種基于學(xué)科的設(shè)計(jì)、實(shí)施與評(píng)價(jià)
評(píng)論
0/150
提交評(píng)論