(完整版)回復審稿人意見模板

1、如何回復SCI投稿審稿人意見（精典語句整理） 如何回復SCI投稿審稿人意見1. 所有問題必須逐條回答。2. 盡量滿足意見中需要補充的實驗。3. 滿足不了的也不要回避，說明不能做的合理理由4. 審稿人推薦的文獻一定要引用，并討論透徹。以下是本人對審稿人意見的回復一例，僅供參考。續(xù)兩點經(jīng)驗：1. 最重要的是逐條回答，即使你答不了，也要老實交代；不要太狡猾，以至于耽誤事；2. 絕大部分實驗是不要真追加的，除非你受到啟發(fā)，而想改投另外高檔雜志-因為你既然已經(jīng)寫成文章，從邏輯上肯定是一個完整的“story 了。以上指國際雜志修稿。國內(nèi)雜志太多，以至于稿源吃緊，基本沒有退稿，所以你 怎么修都是接受。我的文

2、章水平都不高，主要是沒有明顯的創(chuàng)新性，也很苦惱。但是除了開始幾篇 投在國內(nèi)雜志外，其他都在國際雜志（也都是 SCI）發(fā)表。以我了解的情況，我 單位其他同志給國內(nèi)雜志投稿，退稿的極少，只有一次被某某科學進展拒絕。 究其原因，除了我上面說的，另外可能是我單位寫稿子還是比較嚴肅， 導師把關 也比較嚴的緣故。自我感覺總結（不一定對）：1）國內(nèi)雜志審稿極慢（少數(shù)除外），但現(xiàn)在也有加快趨勢；2）國內(nèi)雜志編輯人員認真負責的人不多，稿子寄去后，少則幾個月，多則一年 多沒有任何消息；3）國內(nèi)雜志要求修改的稿子，如果你自己不修，他最后也給你發(fā)；4）國外雜志要求補充實驗的，我均以解釋而過關，原因見少帖）。還因為：很

3、 少雜志編輯把你的修改稿再寄給當初審稿人的，除非審稿人特別請求。編輯不一 定懂你的東西，他只是看到你認真修改，回答疑問了，也就接受了（當然高檔雜志可能不是這樣，我的經(jīng)驗只限定一般雜志（影響因子1-5） o歡迎大家批評指正。我常用的回復格式：Dear reviewer:I am very grateful to your comme nts for the manu script. Accord ing with your advice, we ame nded the releva nt part in manu script. Some of your questi ons were an

4、swered below.1）2)引用審稿人推薦的文獻的確是很重要的，要想辦法和自己的文章有機地結合起 來。至于實驗大部分都可以不用補做，關鍵是你要讓審稿人明白你的文章的重點是什 么，這個實驗對你要強調的重點內(nèi)容不是很必要， 或者你現(xiàn)在所用的方法已經(jīng)可 以達到目的就行了。最后要注意，審稿人也會犯錯誤，不僅僅是筆誤也有專業(yè)知識上的錯誤， 因為編 輯找的審稿人未必是你這個領域的專家。 只要自己是正確的就要堅持。在回復中 委婉地表達一下你的意見，不過要注意商討語氣哦！我得回復格式是這樣的：Dear Professor xx:Thank you very much for your letter da

5、ted xxx xx xxxx, and the referees'reports. Based on your comme nt and request, we have made exte nsive modificati on on the orig inal manu script. Here, we attached revised manu script in the formats of both PDF and MS word, for your approval. A document an sweri ng every questi on from the refe

6、rees was also summarized and en closed.A revised manu script with the correcti on sect ions red marked was attached as the suppleme ntal material and for easy check/edit ing purpose.Should you have any questi ons, please con tact us without hesitate.然后再附上Q/A，基本上囑條回答，寫的越多越好(老師語)。結果修改一次就 接收了：)我的回復，請老外

7、幫忙修改了Dear Editor:Thank you for your kind letter of“ ” on November *, 2005. We revised themanu script in accorda nee with the reviewers' comme nts, and carefullyproof-read the manu script to mini mize typographical, grammatical, and bibliographical errors.Here below is our descriptio n on revisi

8、on accord ing to the reviewers'comme nts.Part A (Reviewer 1)1. The reviewer ' s comment:The authors ' An swer: .2. The reviewer ' s comment:The authors ' An swe.Part B (Reviewer 2)1. The reviewer ' s comment:The authors ' An swer:.2. The reviewer ' s comment:The autho

9、rs ' An swer:.Many grammatical or typographical errors have bee n revised.All the lines and pages in dicated above are in the revised manu script.Thank you and all the reviewers for the kind advice.Sin cerely yours,一個回復的例子(已接收)一、最初投稿 Cover letterDear editor:We would like to submit the enclosedma

10、nuscript entitled“ Paper Title ” , whichwe wish to be co nsidered forpublication in“ Journal Name ” . No conflict ofin terest exits in the submissi onof this manu script, and manu script is approved by all authors for publication.l would like to declare on behalf of my co-authors that the work descr

11、ibed wasorigi nal research that has not bee n published previously, and not un derc on sideratio n for publicati on elsewhere, in whole or in part. All the authorslisted have approved the manu script that is en closed.In this work, we evaluated (簡要介紹一下論文的創(chuàng)新性).1 hope thispaper is suitable for “ Journ

12、al Name ” .The followi ng is a list of possiblereviewers for your con sideratio n:1) Name A E-mail:xxK xxx2) Name B E-mail:xxxX xxxWe deeply appreciate your con siderati on ofour manu script, and we look forward to recei ving comme nts from the reviewers .If you have any queries, please don ' t

13、hesitate to con tact me at the addressbelow.Thank you and best regards.Yours sin cerely,xxxxxxCorresp onding author:Name: xxxE-mail:xx>x< xxx二、催稿信Dear editor:Sorry for disturb ing you. I am not sure ifit is the right time to con tact you toinquire about the status of my submittedmanuscript tit

14、led“Paper Title ” . （ID:文章稿號）,although the status of “With Editor ” has been lasting for more than two mon ths, since submitted tojournal three mon ths ago. I am just won deri ng that my manu script has bee n sen tto reviewers or n ot?s comme nts.I would be greatly appreciated if you couldspend some

15、 of your time check the status for us. I am very pleased to hear fromyou on the reviewerThank you very much for your con siderati on.Best regards!Yours sin cerely,xxxxxxCorresp onding author:Name: xxxE-mail:xx>x< xxx三、修改稿 Cover letterDear Dr/ Prof.（寫上負責你文章編輯的姓名，顯得尊重，因為第一次的投稿不 知道具體負責的編輯，只能用通用的e

16、ditor）:On behalf of my co-authors, we tha nk you very much for giving us an opport un ity to revise our manu script, we appreciate editor and reviewers very much for their positive and con structive comme nts and suggesti ons on our manu script en titled“ Paper Title 文章稿號D：We have studied reviewer &

17、#39; s commensully and have made revision which marked in red in the paper. We have tried our best to revise our manu script accord ing to the comme nts. Attached please find the revised vers ion, which we would like to submit for your kind consideration.We would like to express our greata ppreciati

18、 on to you and reviewers for comme nts on our paper. Look ing forward to heari ng from you.Thank you and best regards.Yours sin cerely,xxxxxxCorresp onding author:Name: xxxE-mail:«x< xxx四、修改稿回答審稿人的意見（最重要的部分）List of Resp on sesDear Editors and Reviewers:Thank you for your letter and for the r

19、eviewers ' comments concerning our manuscript entitled“Paper Title ” (ID: 文章稿號).Those comments are allvaluable and very helpful for revis ing and impro ving ourpaper, as well as the importa nt guid ing sig nifica nee to our researches. We have studied comme nts carefully and have made correct io

20、n which we hope meet with approval.Revised portion are marked in red in the paper. The main correctionsin thepaper and the resp onds to the reviewer's comments wiegas floResp onds to the reviewer's comments:Reviewer #1:1. Response to comment:(-簡要列出意見)Respo nse: xxxxx2. Response to comment:(-

21、簡要列出意見)Respo nse:xxxxx0 0 0 0 0 0逐條意見回答，切忌一定不能有遺漏針對不同的問題有下列幾個禮貌術語可適當用用：We are very sorry for our negligenee ofWe are very sorry for our in correct writ ingIt is really true as Reviewer suggested that We have made correction according to theReviewer ' s comments.We have re-written this part accor

22、ding tothe Reviewer ' s suggestionAs Reviewer suggested that Considering the Reviewer ' s suggestion, wehave 最后特意感謝一下這個審稿人的意見：Special tha nks to you for your goodcomme nts.Reviewer #2:同上述Reviewer #3:xxxxxxOther cha nges:1. Line 60- 61, the statements of“correwfeed as “2. Line 107,“”was added

23、3. Line 129,“”was deletedxxxxxxWe tried our best to improve the manu script and made some cha nges in the manu script. These cha nges will not in flue nee the content and framework of the paper. And here we did no t list the cha nges but marked in red in revised paper.We appreciate for Editors/Revie

24、wers' warmwork earn estly, and hope that thecorrect ion will meet with approval.Once aga in, tha nk you very much for yourcomme nts and suggesti ons.五、文章接受后可以考慮感謝一下負責你文章的編輯或主編（根據(jù)需要）Dear Prof. xxxxx：Thanks very much for your kind work and con sideratio n on publicati on of our paper. On behalf of

25、 my co-authors, we would like to express our great appreciati on to editor and reviewers.Thank you and best regards.Yours sin cerely,xxxxxxCorresp onding author:Name: xxxE-mail: xxxx xxx六、詢問校稿信件（如果文章接受后時間較長）Dear xxSorry for disturb ing you. I am not sure ifit is the right time to con tact you to inq

26、uire about the status of our acceptedmanuscript titled “Paper Title ” （ID: 文 章稿號）,sincethe copyright agreement for publication has been sent to you two mon ths ago. lam just won deri ng that how long I can receive the proof of our manu script fromyou?I would be greatly appreciated if you couldspend some of your time for a reply.I am very ple