版權(quán)說明:本文檔由用戶提供并上傳,收益歸屬內(nèi)容提供方,若內(nèi)容存在侵權(quán),請(qǐng)進(jìn)行舉報(bào)或認(rèn)領(lǐng)
文檔簡介
UNDP
FIELDGUIDEFORHUMANDEVELOPMENTREPORT
2021/2022DIALOGUES
BUILDINGCONDITIONSANDCAPABILITIESTOSHAPENEWFUTURESINUNCERTAINTIMES
FIELDGUIDE
FORHUMAN
DEVELOPMENTREPORT
2021/2022DIALOGUES
BUILDINGCONDITIONSANDCAPABILITIESTO
SHAPENEWFUTURESINUNCERTAINTIMES
ThisUNDPFieldGuidewasauthoredby:
SophiaRobeleandLaurelPatterson,UNDPSDGIntegrationAntoinetteKlatzky,MITPresencingInstitute
With:
PedroConcei??o,TasneemMirza,CarolinaGivenSjolander,HeribertoTapia,UNDPHumanDevelopmentReportOffice
OttoScharmerandKelvyBird,MITPresencingInstitute
AndspecialthankstotheUNDPLeadersfor2030–LeadershipforAwareness-basedSystemsTransformationCertificateProgramme2022cohort:
AliouM.Dia,AnaMaríaDíaz,BalazsHorvath,BettinaWoll,BettyWabunoha,
CarolFlore-Smereczniak,ClaudioTomasi,DianaOfwona,ElsieLaurence-Chounoune,
FrancisJames,GeorgianaBraga-Orillard,InkaMattila,JoseVicenteTroyaRodriguez,
KamilKamaluddeen,KatynaArgueta,LorenzoJiménezdeLuis,MariadelCarmenSacasa,MaleyeDiop,MaribelGutierrez,MathieuCiowela,MatildeMordt,MaxwellGomera,
AoualeMohamedAbchir,NarineSahakyan,NatiaNatsvlishvili,PaLaminBeyai,RoseSsebatindira,SaraFerrerOlivella,StefanLiller,TjarkEgenhoff
ExecutiveSummary
Thisfieldguideoffersideas,practices,andentrypointstodesigndialoguesthatexpandthemodesofcollectivesensing,learninganddecision-makingusedtodealwiththenovelrisksandinsecuritiesunderlinedbytheHumanDevelopmentReport2021/2022:UncertainTimes,UnsettledLives:ShapingourFutureinaTransformingWorld(2021/22HDR).Ashiftingdevelopmentlandscapecallsforshiftsincapabilitiesandmindsetsfordevelopment,whichareshapedbyhowwegatherandconnect,asmuchastheknowledgeswehold.
Thetipsandtoolsinthisguidearenotaboutdialogueforthesakeofdialogue,buttoenablemodesofthinkingandactionconducivetorealizingmoretransformationaloutcomesinthefaceofpolicyuncertaintiesarticulatedbythe2021/22HDR.Ithasbeenco-designedwithUNDP’sfirst‘Leadersfor2030’SystemsTransformationCertificatecohort,bridgingsomeofthetoolsourleadersfoundvaluablefromthecourse,amongothersources,withthediscursivespacesandpolicyprocessesthatinfluencedecision-makingfordevelopment.
Whilethemethodsandtoolsmayberelevantformanydialogue-drivenplanningcontexts,itisspecificallydesignedtosupportnationalandsub-nationalconsultativeexercisesinspiredbyorrelevanttothethemesofthe2021/22HDR.ThetargetaudienceisdevelopmentactorswhoareengagedinHDRprocessesin-country,namelyUNDPleadership,however,itisequallyrelevanttootherpartnersleadingmulti-stakeholderprocessestoinformpolicydirectionsforcomplex,systemicchallenges.Thoughanticipatedthataprimaryuserwillbedialoguefacilitators,theguideequallyinvitesrenewedperspectiveontheroleofseniorleadersatthemidpointinthe2030Agenda–offeringpathwaysforthemtoconsidertheiruniquepotentialtoinfluencechangeprocessesbyservingasdesignersofconditionsandarchitectsofrelationships.
Theguideisdividedintothreemainsections:
.Thefirstsectionsupportsleaderstoestablishthebaselineconditionsforagrouptoconnect,sothattheyfeelsafetothinkoutsidethebox,challengeeachotheringenerativeways,orexpresswhatneedstobesaid.Itincludesguidanceonstakeholderengagementandconsiderationofdialogueformatsandcomponentsmostrelevanttodifferentneeds.
.ThesecondsectionchartstwodifferentHDR‘frames’whichreflectdifferentintentionsinestablishingdialogue.Thefirstistheuseofgenerativedialoguetochartnewpolicyhorizons,completewithsampletopics,designconsiderations,tipsandtools.Thissectionismostapplicabletoissuesthatarefastchanging,withoutprecedentoradequateanchoringinpolicydiscourse.ThesecondHDRframesupportsareinvigorationoffoundationalvaluesandprinciples.Similartotheprecedingsection,thisincludessampletopicstohelpassessifthisisthebestfitforparticularcontextandneeds,withdesignconsiderations,tipsandtools.
EXECUTIVESUMMARY3
.Thefinalsectionsupportsleadersandfacilitatorstonavigateuncertaintyaspartofthedialogueprocess,withcrosscuttingmethods,futures-orientedapproachesandconsiderationofrolesandpartnershipstoadvancetransformationalchange.
Inclosing,webrieflyexploremethodstotrackprogress,andtipstostayontrack.Keyprinciplesthreadedthroughoutallsectionsinclude:
.Examiningpoweratallstagesofthedialogue:Lookingbeyondwhoisincluded,towhattheyarebeingincludedinto–fromtherulesofengagement,tothewaysthatdifferentmodesofcommunicationandbeliefsabouttheworldareinvitedintoadialoguespace.
.Expandingourunderstandingofwhatconstitutesasystemanddrivesrisks:Harnessingdiverseperspectivesisnotjustaboutlisteningtomorepeopleorcollectingmoredata,butalsoexpandingthewayswelisten,therelationshipsweestablish,andouropennesstobeingchangedintheprocess.
.Makingspaceforideastosettleandtransform,suchasbybookendingcyclesofactionanddiscoursewithmomentsofstillness,reflectionorart,toensurethatlearninghasachancetocrystallizeintocreativityandinnovation.
ThisfieldguidewillcontinuetoevolvewithpracticeandnewinsightsfromUNDPandotherpractitioners.Continuousfeedbackandlearningareparamounttothisinitiative–youwillfindcontactpointsattheendofthisreportandlinkstoadedicatedwebspaceonUNDP’sknowledgeplatform,
SparkBlue.
EXECUTIVESUMMARY4
TABLEOF
CONTENTS
Thisfieldguideisnotastep-by-stepmanual,butbetterunderstoodasacompass.Wewelcomeyoutoexploreandjumparoundbasedonyourneeds.
EXECUTIVESUMMARY
3
RATIONALEFORTHISGUIDE
6
WHYTHISFIELDGUIDE?
7
WHEREMIGHTITAPPLY?
9
SCENESETTING
11
SHAPINGTHECONTAINER1
2
SELECTINGSTAKEHOLDERS
14
DIALOGUEELEMENTSANDFORMATS1
5
HDRFRAMESANDENTRYPOINTSFORDIALOGUE
20
FRAME1:
CHARTINGNEWPOLICYHORIZONS
21
SAMPLEHDRTOPICS2
3
DESIGNCONSIDERATIONS2
3
TOOLSANDMETHODS2
4
FRAME2:
REINVIGORATINGFOUNDATIONALVALUESANDPRINCIPLES2
6
SAMPLEHDRTOPICS2
8
DESIGNCONSIDERATIONS2
8
TOOLSANDMETHODS2
9
NAVIGATINGUNCERTAINTYTHROUGHDIALOGUE3
2
CROSS-CUTTINGMETHODS:
THINKANDWORKINMOREFUTURE-FITWAYS3
3
RE-EXAMINEROLESANDPARTNERSHIPSTOENABLETRANSFORMATION3
5
WHATTOEXPECT,WHATTOTRACK3
9
MAINTAININGTHEMOMENTUM
42
ANNEX:KEYMESSAGES4
4
Rationaleforthisguide
Whythisfieldguide?
Wheremightitapply?
Whythisfieldguide?
Thisfieldguideoffersideas,practices,andentrypointstodesigndialoguesthatexpandthemodesofcollectivesensing,learninganddecision-makingusedtodealwiththecomplexityofthechallengesreflectedintheHumanDevelopmentReport2021/2022:UncertainTimes,UnsettledLives:ShapingourFutureinaTransformingWorld(2021/22HDR).
The2021/22HDRadvancesanewuncertaintycomplex:aworldinwhichwenotonlyfacenewrisksandsourcesofhumaninsecurity,butoneinwhich“novellayersofuncertaintiesareinteractingtocreatenewkindsofuncertainty.”iFromdestabilizedplanetarysystemsintheAnthropocene,tothespreadofpoliticalpolarizationandsocietalfractions,tothesweepingsocietaltransformationsneededtotransitiontoastableclimateregime,theconvergenceoftheserealitiescompelsnewdevelopmentmodels,knowledgeframeworks,andriskmanagementapproaches.
Whenitcomestoarrivingatsolutionsfitfor21stcenturychallenges,weoftenfailtoharnessthefullpotentialofdialogue–oneofourmostpowerfulsocialtechnologies–tohelpusgetthere.Ashiftingdevelopmentlandscapecallsforshiftsincapabilitiesandmindsetsfordevelopment.Designingdialogueswithaneyetoawareness-drivenandrelationship-centeredpracticesisanimportantchannelforrealizingtheseshifts.
Puttingthefocusongenerativedialogue1isalsoawaytotendtoourinteriorconditionandtherelationshipsthatshapecollectivethinkingandaction.Dialogueunderpinnedbydeeplistening,trust,andopenness,isamongtheprimaryvehiclesbywhichweforgesharedmeaningandpossibilities,fosternewcapabilitiesforaction,andestablishrelationshipsnecessaryfornewwaysofworking.
Unlessweapproachdialogueasanoutcomewehavetheagencyandresponsibilitytodesignfor,wetendtoproceedwitholdpatternsofconversationthatproducesimilarapproachesandresultswe’vewitnessedinthepast.
ThisFieldGuiderespondstoakeychallengepresentedbythe2021/22HDR–acalltoreimaginenotonlywhatwedo,buthow.Itbuildsfrom
UNDP’sglobaldialoguesonawareness-basedcollective
action
undertakenfrom2020,an
ActionLearningLab
withsevenUNentitiesin2021,andaPeoplefor2030certificateprogrammein2022thatsupportedleaderstodrawonintrospectivepracticesandtheartstobetterunderstandtherootsofsystemicchallengesandunlocknewpossibilitiesforchange.
1Notethatthisfieldguideusestheword“dialogue”asadistinctformofcommunication,inspiredby
Bohmiandefinitions
:“Adialoguehasnopredefinedpurpose[…]otherthanthatofinquiringintothemovementofthought,andexploringtheprocessof‘thinkingtogether’collectively.[…]itmayturnoutthatsuchaformoffreeexchangeofideasandinformationisoffundamentalrelevancefortransformingcultureandfreeingitofdestructivemisinformation,sothatcreativitycanbeliberated.”
RATIONALEFORTHISGUIDE7
Theguidewasco-designedwithUNDPResidentRepresentativesfromthefirstcohortofthecertificateprogrammeanddrawsfrommanydialogicpracticesandmethodsbasedinthePresencingInstitute’s
TheoryU
framework.Theintentionistoshareexperiencesandlessonsfromadvancingsuchdialogues,tohelppartnersadvancetheinsightsfromthe2021/22HDR.
Visualscribeofaco-designdiscussionwithResidentRepresentativesfromtheLeadershipforAwareness-basedSystemsTransformationCertificatethatinformedthisfieldguide.August2022.ByKelvyBird
Whoisthisfieldguidefor?
Whilethemethodsandtoolsofferedinthisguidemayberelevantformanydialogue-drivenpolicyplanningcontexts,itisspecificallydesignedtosupportdevelopmentactorswithnationalandsub-nationalconsultativeexercisesinspiredbyorrelevanttothethemesofthe2021/22HDR.
TheprimaryaudienceisdevelopmentactorswhoareengagedinHDRprocessesin-country–namelyUNDPleadership;however,itisequallyrelevanttootherpartnersinvolvedinHDRprocessesordialoguethatrelatestoformulatingpolicydirectionsoncomplex,uncertainchallenges.
Theguideofferswaysforleaderstoconsidertheirpowerandinfluenceasdesignersofconditionsandarchitectsofrelationships,underliningthat“creatingthespaceforchangeandenablingcollectiveintelligencetoemerge”iiisamongthecriticalcompetenciesrequiredforleadershipintheDecadeofAction.
RATIONALEFORTHISGUIDE8
Wheremightitapply?
Thisguideisnotintendedtoreplaceexistingspaceswheremeaningfulexchangetoadvancedevelopmentprogressmayalreadybeunderway.Rather,itisaboutstrategicallyexaminingareaswheretheremaybegapswhenitcomestodesigningdialoguestailoredtothekindsofcomplexchallengesandnoveluncertaintiesarticulatedbythe2021/22HDR.Amongtheentrypointsmightbe:
.NationalorlocalVoluntaryNationalReviews.Nationaldevelopmentplanningprocesses
.Consultativespacesonthemarginsofhigh-levelevents
.
Mission-oriented
innovationprocesses
.DesigningjointprogramminginspiredbytheHDR
.SDGlocalizationplatforms[
example
]
.Socialcohesioninitiatives[
example
]
Examples
Spreadingthereachanddepthofahigh-leveldialogueprocess–InsightsfromFoodSystemsSummit2021Dialogues
Dialoguesinthe2021FoodSystemsSummitenableddiverselocalitiestoconveneandcuratetheirownIndependentDialoguesalongsidetheMemberStateandGlobalDialoguestocollectivelyinformprogressoffoodandagricultureissues.Thisgaveinterestgroupsastandardizedapproachtodrawonfordialogue,includingsuggestionsforcoreroles,possibleformats,andexampletopicsandprompts.Theprocesshelpedencouragediverseactorstoholdthespaceforopenexchange.Thiscombinationofstructuredandopen-dialoguespacesenabledinterestedstakeholderstobetheco-creatorsofdialogueintheirowncontexts,whilehavingsomedirectionandentrypointstogetstarted.
ReadmoreabouttheSummitDialoguesmethod
here
,aswellasarecommendedrunofshow
here
.
RATIONALEFORTHISGUIDE9
IntegratingimaginationintonationalplanninginNorthMacedonia
InNorthMacedonia,UNDPsoughttoredesignthewayinstitutionscreate,implement,andmonitorparticipatorypublicstrategiesandplanstobemorefutures-oriented.Thisincludedembeddingimaginationandconnectingunlikelyplayersindialoguestoinformthedesignofa20-yearNationalDevelopmentStrategy.Thefutureimaginingexerciseinvolvedmorethan1,000people–fromyouthtomayors–inaseriesofvisioningworkshops,called“DreamLabs.”Participantswereguidedtore-thinkpresentchallenges,considerwhattypesoffuturestheywantedtobuildascommunities,andconnectthesevisionstopolicydecisions.Animportantelementwasalsotonotpit‘traditional’insightsourcesforpolicyagainstthoseemergingfromimagination.Theteamalsocreatedavirtualplatformtoshareoutcomesoftheseprocesseswithfeedbackloops,tobuildcontinuity.
Learnmore
here
.
Developingdeeplisteningandcollectivesense-makingcapabilitiesthroughSocialInnovationPlatforms
ThroughSocialInnovationPlatforms,UNDPAsiaandthePacificregionhasexperimentedwaystoconnectactors,methods,andinterconnectedactionsforamoresystemicapproachtodevelopmentchallenges.Akeydimensionwasmethodsfordeeplistening,sensemakingandco-productiontofacilitatecivicspacesforinclusiveparticipationandcollaboration.InIndonesia,UNDPengagedfishers,mothers,micro-businessownersandlocalauthoritiesinGorontaloandWestJavain‘DeepListening’exercisesearlyinthepandemictoassesstheimpactofCOVID-19onSDGprogress.Thesefacilitationmethodshelpedtocaptureandanalysehiddennarrativesinthecommunities,toinformthedesignofaportfolioofsolutionsandprototypestobooststrategiesandawarenessinaddressingexistingchallenges,suchasunequalaccesstocleanwaterandunsustainabletourism.
MoreonUNDPSocialInnovationPlatforms
here
.
RATIONALEFORTHISGUIDE10
r
Scenesetting
Shapingthecontainer
Selectingstakeholders
Dialogueelementsandformats
Shapingthecontainer
Containerbuildingistheprocessofcreatingasafespaceforagrouporteambyestablishingbothtrustandgroundrulesforengagement.Acontainerinthiscontextisdefinedbytheboundariesofasocialfieldandincorporatesthreequalities:openmind(seeing),openheart(feeling),andopenwill(intention).Thissetsthetoneforajourneythatisabouttounfoldbyprovidingasafespaceforrisk-takinginanatmospherethatsupportsgrowthandlearning.
Containerbuildingisdoneatthebeginningofasocialprocess(inpersonorremote)andestablishesfoundationforagroup.Byintentionallycreatingacontainer,leadersimprovehowparticipantspayattention,interact,andcollaborate.2
Gettingstarted
Step1:Intentionsetting
Containerbuildingrequirespreparation.Theprocessincludespayingattentiontotheinnerconditionofthefacilitatorandoftheparticipants.
Innerconditionsofthefacilitator(s):
TheoryU
statesthattheinnerconditionoftheintervenordefinesthesuccessofanintervention.Themorecomplexaprocess,thedeeperthisexplorationshouldbe.Thefollowingquestionscanassistthefacilitatorsinevaluatingtheirowninnercondition.Answerthemwithabriefjournalingprocess.Youmightalsogoonawalkwithyourco-facilitatorormentortoreflectonthem:
.WhyamIdoingthiswork?Whatismyintentionfortheprocess?
.WhenIthinkaboutthiswork,whatemotionscomeup?WhatamIfeelinginmybody?
.Whataboutmycurrentworkandlifeinspiresandenergizesmethemost?HowcanIchannelthisenergyintothewaysIbuildthisspaceforothers?
Innerconditionsoftheparticipants:Preparationcanalsoincludetheparticipants,bydeepeningtheirawarenessoftheworkahead.Notallprocessesrequirethis.Butthemorecomplexasituation,themorethiswillhelpthework.Somepracticeoptionsinclude:
2Additionalresourcesoncontainerbuilding:Bird,Kelvy(2018).GenerativeScribing:AnArtofthe21stCentury.Cambridge,MA:PIPress.Cecil,Barbara,GlenniferGillespie,andOttoScharmer(2003).“ThePresenceoftheCircleBeing:ConversationwiththeCircleofSeven.”DialogueonLeadershipInterviews,
.Isaacs,William(1999).Dialogue:TheArtofThinkingTogether.NewYork:Currency-Doubleday.Scharmer,Otto(2018).TheEssentialsofTheoryU,Chapter5.Oakland,CA:Berrett-Koehler.
SCENESETTING12
.Organizeenrollmentinterviewswithparticipants.
.Askparticipantstoconduct
StakeholderInterviews
.
.Setupamentorshiporpeerlearningbetweenparticipants.
Step2:Initiatetheprocess
.Usecheck-insandintroductionsasaninvitationforeveryonetoparticipateandfeelwelcome..Facilitateagreementonthe“whatandhow”regardingtheagendaandprocess.
.Establishconnectionsbetweeneveryoneintheroom—forexample,byhearingeachvoice(ifthegroupislarge,splitintosmallergroups).
Step3:Facilitatetheholdingspacefordifferencestoarise
Activelyexpandyourownawarenesstohelpothersopenupanddealwithtensions.Startbypayingattentiontoyourposture,tohowyouarestandingorsittingwhenyouareinthegroup,andtoyourbreath.Practicebroadeningyourawarenessofthesocialfieldbyaskingyourself:
.Whatishardforyoutosee,hold,orsupportinthesystem?.Whereareresourcesandpointsofstrength?
.Whoisbeingexcluded?Whatvoicesarenotbeingheard?.Whatemotionscomeupforyou?Why?
Theseregularreflectionscanhelpyoustrengthenyourqualityoflistening(seeLevelsofListeningframeworkbelow),inordertobetterrespondtotheneedsofparticipants.
Levelsoflistening
Thefirststepinunderstandingtheimpactofattentiononrealityistolookatourownindividualpracticeoflistening.
Seeworksheethere
Source:Scharmer,O.(2018).TheEssentialsofTheoryU:CorePrinciplesandApplications.
Findmoreideasoncultivatingmindfulnessforsystemicactioninthereport
Reconnection:Meeting
theClimateCrisisInsideOut(2022)
SCENESETTING13
Toolsandconsiderationsforstakeholderselection
Whilemyriadresourcesexisttoinformstakeholderselection–fromin-depthpoliticaleconomyanalysistostandardstakeholdermapping–itisworthhighlightingjustafewrelevantconsiderationsandtoolshere.
DeterminingkeyactorsforanHDRdialogueprocessoriginatesfromanunderstandingofthescopeandfocusoftheissuesandsystemsbeingexaminedandhowdifferentactorsinfluenceandareinfluencedbythem.
.Refertothe
UNDGPost-2015DevelopmentAgenda:GuidelinesforCountryDialogues
(2012)p.20andAnnex2.1“ListofStakeholderGroups”forsomestakeholderidentificationrecommendations.
.Aframeworkthatcansupportmappingofindividualactors,theirinterrelationshipsandpossibleperspectivesinrelationtothechallengesbeingdiscussedisfoundin
DemocraticDialogue–A
HandbookforPractitioners
(2007)Box2.2.1“AFrameworkforActorMapping”(p.61).
.The
SystemicDesignToolkit(2021)
“Richcontext:framingthesystem”exercise(p.8),
this
framework
to“exploreissuesdrivingasystemsinquiry”from
DesignJourneysthroughComplex
Systems
(2022),orthe
NestaCollectiveIntelligenceDesignPlaybook
“stakeholdermap”(p.78)canhelptomapthecurrentdynamicsofasystemasabasistoidentifyparticipants.
.The
WorldBankPublic-PrivateDialogueStakeholderMappingToolkit
(2016)’s“Net-mapmethod”(seep.13)and“elementsforstakeholdermapping”(p.10,Table2)canalsohelptounpackthekeyactorsandtheirlinks,influences,andintereststoadialogueprocess.
.Workingtowardsmoreinclusivedialoguespacesrequiresrecognizingthelimitsofourownunderstandingsandassumptions.Onewaytoembedthisawarenessintostakeholderidentificationistoexpandcapacitiestolistenfromthemarginsofasystem,supportedbytoolslike
StakeholderInterviews
and
EmpathyWalks
.
.Foridentifyingthecoregroupwhowilldriveandsustainthedialogueprocess,youmightconsiderthemixofcompetenciesimportantforpublicsectorinnovation.The“Mappingateam’sinnovationcompetencies”activityinNesta’sguideto
Skills,attitudesandbehavioursthatfuel
publicinnovation
,p.59canhelp.
.Makesureyougiveasmuchattentiontohowyouincludepeople,includingtheresourcesand
timerequiredtoaddresspowerdifferentialsandcreatesafespaces,asyougivetowhoyouinclude.Sometoolstosupportthiscanbefoundinthis
FieldGuidetoPowerLiteracy,
particularlytheRolePowerWorksheet;theUNPRPD-UNWomen
IntersectionalityResourceGuideandToolkit
(2022)
;andthe
UNDPSystems,Power,andGender(2022)
paper.
SCENESETTING14
Dialogueelementsandformats
Whilethisguideoffersarangeofdialoguetools,ifyouhavetimefornothingelse,considerplayingwiththeformatofthespaceasawaytodisruptoldpatternsofthinkingandcollaboration.Structuralelements–fromgroupsizetothetimeallocatedforsilentreflection–significantlyinfluencethewayspeoplethink,learn,anddeliberatetogether.
Asyoustructurethesessions,consideravarietyofelementsastoolsinyourkit:
Plenaryoropensessions:Theseareusefulatthebeginningandendofasession–feelingthemagnitudeofthewholeofthegrouptogethercanofferasenseofbeingpartofsomethinglarger.
Plenarywithspeaker:Oftenhavingaspeakerwhocanbringinapieceofthecontenttakesthepressureoffthegroupasawhole.Engagingspeakerssparkdialogueorofferapracticetodeepenthecontent.
Smallgroups:Movingintosmallergroups(~3-5)increasesthesenseofagencyfortheparticipants.Smallgroupscanbeusedtogettotheheartofspecificthemesorareasofinterest,orcreateintimacyandvulnerabilitywithinopendiscussions.
Self-reflectionmoments:Inanyconversation,dialogue,oractivity,amomentofpausecanofferabreakinthesteadystreamandopenaspaceforashiftinperspective.Momentsofreflectioncanalsobejournalingorsilentreflectivepractice.
Continuoussmallgroups:IncludedinthisguidearewhatPresencingInstitutecalls
CaseClinics
,whichofferoneformofstructureddialogueforcontinuedconnectionandgrowth.Youmayinvitesmallgroupsof4-7tocontinuemeetingonaregularbasisforaparticularperiodoftimetosharearoundspecificHDRthemes.
SocialArt:Invitesanadva
溫馨提示
- 1. 本站所有資源如無特殊說明,都需要本地電腦安裝OFFICE2007和PDF閱讀器。圖紙軟件為CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.壓縮文件請(qǐng)下載最新的WinRAR軟件解壓。
- 2. 本站的文檔不包含任何第三方提供的附件圖紙等,如果需要附件,請(qǐng)聯(lián)系上傳者。文件的所有權(quán)益歸上傳用戶所有。
- 3. 本站RAR壓縮包中若帶圖紙,網(wǎng)頁內(nèi)容里面會(huì)有圖紙預(yù)覽,若沒有圖紙預(yù)覽就沒有圖紙。
- 4. 未經(jīng)權(quán)益所有人同意不得將文件中的內(nèi)容挪作商業(yè)或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文庫網(wǎng)僅提供信息存儲(chǔ)空間,僅對(duì)用戶上傳內(nèi)容的表現(xiàn)方式做保護(hù)處理,對(duì)用戶上傳分享的文檔內(nèi)容本身不做任何修改或編輯,并不能對(duì)任何下載內(nèi)容負(fù)責(zé)。
- 6. 下載文件中如有侵權(quán)或不適當(dāng)內(nèi)容,請(qǐng)與我們聯(lián)系,我們立即糾正。
- 7. 本站不保證下載資源的準(zhǔn)確性、安全性和完整性, 同時(shí)也不承擔(dān)用戶因使用這些下載資源對(duì)自己和他人造成任何形式的傷害或損失。
最新文檔
- 中國政法大學(xué)《工程中的數(shù)值方法C》2023-2024學(xué)年第一學(xué)期期末試卷
- 鄭州西亞斯學(xué)院《現(xiàn)代通信原理》2023-2024學(xué)年第一學(xué)期期末試卷
- 長江工程職業(yè)技術(shù)學(xué)院《公共服務(wù)質(zhì)量管理》2023-2024學(xué)年第一學(xué)期期末試卷
- 消費(fèi)級(jí)3D打印機(jī)打印精度改進(jìn)
- 保險(xiǎn)行業(yè)基礎(chǔ)講解模板
- 業(yè)務(wù)操作-房地產(chǎn)經(jīng)紀(jì)人《業(yè)務(wù)操作》名師預(yù)測卷4
- 開學(xué)晨會(huì)發(fā)言稿
- 二零二五年政府形象廣告服務(wù)合同規(guī)范
- 二零二五版國際學(xué)校外教引進(jìn)與團(tuán)隊(duì)建設(shè)協(xié)議3篇
- 2024-2025學(xué)年新疆烏魯木齊四十一中高二(上)期末數(shù)學(xué)試卷(含答案)
- 《道路交通安全法》課件完整版
- 向女朋友認(rèn)錯(cuò)保證書范文
- 五分?jǐn)?shù)加法和減法(課件)-數(shù)學(xué)五年級(jí)下冊
- 2024年四川省綿陽市中考語文試卷(附真題答案)
- 設(shè)計(jì)材料與工藝課程 課件 第1章 產(chǎn)品設(shè)計(jì)材料與工藝概述
- 幼兒園反恐防暴技能培訓(xùn)內(nèi)容
- 食品企業(yè)質(zhì)檢員聘用合同
- 中醫(yī)診所內(nèi)外部審計(jì)制度
- 自然辯證法學(xué)習(xí)通超星期末考試答案章節(jié)答案2024年
- 2024年國家危險(xiǎn)化學(xué)品經(jīng)營單位安全生產(chǎn)考試題庫(含答案)
- 護(hù)理員技能培訓(xùn)課件
評(píng)論
0/150
提交評(píng)論