布線廠商產(chǎn)品質(zhì)量測(cè)試報(bào)告

布線廠商產(chǎn)品質(zhì)量測(cè)試報(bào)告:該五家布線廠商為現(xiàn)今國(guó)內(nèi)布線市場(chǎng)中的主要生產(chǎn)廠家,五家布線廠商分別在不同時(shí)期進(jìn)入中國(guó)市場(chǎng)，各自的產(chǎn)品背景的不同造成各自的市場(chǎng)定位，市場(chǎng)價(jià)格，市場(chǎng)份額不同。廠家的產(chǎn)品質(zhì)量雖說(shuō)相差不大,但畢竟有所不同,今次便通過(guò)相應(yīng)的產(chǎn)品技術(shù)測(cè)試進(jìn)行產(chǎn)品質(zhì)量的比較，從而在純技術(shù)方面進(jìn)行比較。布線廠商簡(jiǎn)介：廠商布線部門(mén)產(chǎn)品電氣標(biāo)準(zhǔn)線纜類型TYCOAmpnetconnectULCMAVAYASystimaxCE，ULCMKRONEKronecommumcationULCMIBDNNordx/cdtETL，CSA，ULCMRSIEMONSiemoncablingsystemULCMX簡(jiǎn)明目錄：材質(zhì)比較重量銅線線芯線徑線纜外表皮直徑銅線線芯絞距測(cè)試報(bào)告結(jié)論材質(zhì)比較測(cè)試工具：重量稱，千分尺，普通尺LANCableMeasuringDataRecordPartNumber

Description:

Category5E,4UTP,24AWG,InspectiondateVenderConductor(mm)

Cable(mm)Weight(kg)Data1Data2Data3Average

Data1Data2Data3Data4AverageData2002-6-4KRONE0.5130.5140.5130.513

4.945.535.025.415.239.450.5130.5110.5110.512

5.604.965.415.195.29

2002-6-4SIEMON0.5230.5210.5210.522

4.695.575.604.695.149.000.5230.5230.5210.522

4.744.815.525.575.16

2002-6-5AVAYA0.5090.5090.5080.509

4.905.255.025.365.138.500.5070.5080.5080.508

4.685.684.665.565.15

2002-6-5IBDN0.5010.5020.5000.501

4.404.384.514.324.407.450.5030.5040.5030.503

4.524.414.644.324.47

2002-6-5AMP6-219586-40.5220.5210.5210.521

5.235.025.415.115.199.300.5170.5180.5190.518

5.125.225.235.305.22

2002-6-5AMP6-219507-4(0222)0.5150.5170.5160.516

4.844.895.515.625.229.850.5160.5140.5160.515

4.754.865.515.585.18

重量 大家可以來(lái)比較一下重量，IBDN是最輕的，AVAYA和SIEMON為其次，KRONE和AMP（6-219586-4）較重，AMP（6-219507-4）為最好。重量其實(shí)是非常直觀的參數(shù),用戶最容易了解到的參數(shù)便是重量。當(dāng)然重量最重的未必是最好的，但重量往往體現(xiàn)材質(zhì)的基本好壞，而IBDN的7.45公斤的表現(xiàn)未免太令人失望,有點(diǎn)偷工減料的嫌疑。AVAYA和SIEMON的表現(xiàn)也不是很好，相對(duì)來(lái)說(shuō)AMP和KRONE的表現(xiàn)為最好。銅線線芯線徑 銅線線芯線徑問(wèn)題。銅線線芯線徑是影響線纜性能的直接因素，特別對(duì)于超五類系統(tǒng)和六類系統(tǒng)來(lái)說(shuō),線徑的變化是影響布線網(wǎng)絡(luò)所有性能的重要參數(shù)，尤其是回波損耗和衰減。超五類線纜的線徑國(guó)際標(biāo)準(zhǔn)是24AWG，大約0.511mm。但從測(cè)試報(bào)告來(lái)看，IBDN和AVAYA根本不符合24AWG的國(guó)際標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，IBDN甚至只有0.501mm的線徑，KRONE為其次，AMP和SIEMON為最好。線纜外表皮直徑 線纜外表皮直徑也是相當(dāng)重要的，這關(guān)系到線纜外表皮的厚度，從而體現(xiàn)線纜的抗磨程度。這在實(shí)際施工過(guò)程中是相當(dāng)重要的，并且，線纜外表皮越厚，就越能抵抗外界溫度的變化。相信大家不愿意用一拉就壞，一冷就裂的劣質(zhì)線纜。從測(cè)試報(bào)告來(lái)看，IBDN的線纜外表皮直徑又是最細(xì)的，只有4.5不到。AVAYA和SIEMON為其次，AMP和KRONE為最好。 銅線線芯絞距銅線線芯絞距往往是大家忽視的重要參數(shù)，銅線線芯絞距的密與疏往往會(huì)影響布線網(wǎng)絡(luò)的近端串?dāng)_這個(gè)參數(shù)，而且銅線線芯絞距的穩(wěn)定亦會(huì)影響網(wǎng)絡(luò)鏈路的阻抗，從而影響回波損耗這個(gè)參數(shù)。現(xiàn)測(cè)試結(jié)果如下：以5CM為標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，測(cè)試四對(duì)銅線線芯絞合對(duì)數(shù)5CMKRONESIEMONAVAYAIBDN6-219586-46-219507-4Data1767868Data261086117Data3877876Data4686598數(shù)據(jù)表明，AMP和SIEMON較好，銅線線芯絞距疏落有致，線對(duì)與線對(duì)之間互不干擾。而KRONE，AVAYA和IBDN就表現(xiàn)不是很好，IBDN更有點(diǎn)偷工減料的嫌疑，竟是1CM一個(gè)絞合。 測(cè)試報(bào)告無(wú)論重量，銅線線芯線徑，線纜外表皮直徑，銅線線芯絞距有何差異，但這些只是一些表面的判別依據(jù)，測(cè)試結(jié)果應(yīng)該是最有說(shuō)服力。測(cè)試儀器：FLUKEDSP4000測(cè)試環(huán)境：100米線纜，2個(gè)模塊（各自廠家產(chǎn)品互為配套）測(cè)試方式：FLUKE永久鏈路模塊（PM01，PM02，PM03）測(cè)試標(biāo)準(zhǔn)：TIA/EIA568B-超五類標(biāo)準(zhǔn)由于FLUKE的永久鏈路模塊有三種（PM01，PM02，PM03），因此為公平起見(jiàn)，各家布線廠商的均測(cè)試（PM01，PM02，PM03）。報(bào)告如下：AMPNETCONNECT6-219586-4PM01CableID:TestSummary:PASSAMPHEADROOM7.8NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200203:33:34pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)107107109107Anomaly(m)Length(m)90.888.187.189.6Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)439426421433Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)185012Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAMPNETCONNECT6-219586-4PM02CableID:TestSummary:PASSAMPHEADROOM7.7NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200203:39:53pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)106107108107Anomaly(m)Length(m)90.888.187.389.6Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)439426422433Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)174011Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAMPNETCONNECT6-219586-4PM03CableID:TestSummary:PASSAMPHEADROOM7.4NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200203:41:43pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)107107108107Anomaly(m)Length(m)90.888.187.189.6Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)439426421433Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)185012Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAMPNETCONNECT6-219507-4PM01CableID:TestSummary:PASSAMPHEADROOM6.3NEXTSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200203:17:12pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)111110109105Anomaly(m)Length(m)87.187.988.189.4Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)421425426432Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)04511Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAMPNETCONNECT6-219507-4PM02CableID:TestSummary:PASSYourCompanyNameHEADROOM6.6NEXTSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200203:11:20pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)110109109105Anomaly(m)Length(m)86.987.988.588.9Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)420425428430Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)05810Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAMPNETCONNECT6-219507-4PM03CableID:TestSummary:PASSAMPHEADROOM5.1NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200203:09:20pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)111109109105Anomaly(m)Length(m)87.187.988.389.4Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)421425427432Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)04611Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSKRONEPM01CableID:TestSummary:PASSKRONEHEADROOM5.1NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200202:31:36pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)108107108108Anomaly(m)Length(m)89.291.290.288.7Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)431441436429Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)21270Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSKRONEPM02CableID:TestSummary:PASSKRONEHEADROOM4.9NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200202:29:45pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)108107108107Anomaly(m)Length(m)89.29190.288.7Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)431440436429Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)21170Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSKRONEPM03CableID:TestSummary:PASSKRONEHEADROOM4.9NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200202:27:52pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)108107108108Anomaly(m)Length(m)89.29190.288.7Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)431440436429Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)21170Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSSIEMONPM01CableID:TestSummary:PASSSIEMONHEADROOM9.2NEXTSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200202:45:18pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)106107107108Anomaly(m)Length(m)88.991.888.190.4Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)430444426437Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)418011Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSSIEMONPM02CableID:TestSummary:PASSSIEMONHEADROOM9.7NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200202:47:20pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)106107107107Anomaly(m)Length(m)88.791.888.190.2Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)429444426436Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)318010Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSSIEMONPM03CableID:TestSummary:PASSSIEMONHEADROOM9.9NEXTSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200202:49:47pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)106106107107Anomaly(m)Length(m)88.791.888.190.2Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)429444426436Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)318010Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAVAYAPM01CableID:TestSummary:PASSAVAYAHEADROOM4.3NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200201:23:57pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)109107109107Anomaly(m)Length(m)87.989.287.588.9Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)425431423430Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)2807Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAVAYAPM02CableID:TestSummary:PASSAVAYAHEADROOM5.0NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200201:28:25pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)109107109107Anomaly(m)Length(m)88.389.287.588.9Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)427431423430Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)4807Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSAVAYAPM03CableID:TestSummary:PASSAVAYAHEADROOM4.9NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/11/200201:31:38pmOPERATOR:YourNameTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)109107109107Anomaly(m)Length(m)88.389.287.588.7Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)427431423429Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)4806Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSIBDNPM01CableID:TestSummary:FAILIBDNHEADROOM5.2NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/20/200211:07:42amOPERATOR:SYMTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)105104104105Anomaly(m)Length(m)88.790.690.889.2Limit(m)90909090ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSProp.Delay(ns)429438439431Limit(ns)498498498498ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSDelaySkew(ns)09102Limit(ns)44444444ResultPASSPASSPASSPASSIBDNPM02CableID:TestSummary:PASSIBDNHEADROOM5.2NEXT@RemoteSITE:ClientNameDate/Time:06/20/200211:12:07amOPERATOR:SYMTestStandard:TIACat5ePerm.LinkStandardsVersion:4.8CableType:UTP100OhmCat5eSoftwareVersion:3.8FLUKEDSP-4000S/N:7666050PM-NVP:69.00%FAULTANOMALYTHRESHOLD:15%FLUKEDSP-4000SRS/N:7666050PM-ShieldTest:N/AWireMapPASSResultRJ45PIN:1234||||RJ45PIN:1234Pair1,23,64,57,8Impedance(ohms)10510410410