2024年甘肅省職業(yè)院校技能大賽高職組英語口語（師生同賽）樣卷4

職場辯論

每隊參賽教師和參賽學生自行分配一辯、二辯角色，根據(jù)抽簽結(jié)果與另一隊就一道辯題進行

現(xiàn)場辯論。先由正方一辯陳述1分鐘，然后由反方一辯陳述1分鐘；接下來由正反雙方進行

3分鐘的自由辯論；最后先由反方二辯作1分鐘總結(jié)陳詞，再由正方二辯作1分鐘總結(jié)陳詞。

本環(huán)節(jié)現(xiàn)場備賽10分鐘

比賽時長：7分鐘

分值：10分

No.1

Background:ChatGPT(GenerativePre-trainedTransformer)isanAI-enabled

model,whichhasgainedwidespreadattentionduetoitsabilitytogenerate

natural-soundingresponsestoprompts,andtowriteessays,papers,andstories,etc.

Thephenomenahavecausededucatorstoworryabouttheacademicintegrityinthe

fieldofeducation,withsomeuniversitiesbanningtheuseofit.

Ourquestion:DoyouthinkChatGPTineducationisafriendorafoe?

Pro:IthinkChatGPTineducationisafriend.

Con:ChatGPTineducationisafoe.

No.2

Background:Ashiftfromgas-poweredautomobilestoelectriconesisunderway

thankstovariousfactorssuchasgovernmentincentives,advancementsinbatterytech,

andincreasedpublicawarenessonthenegativeenvironmentaleffectsoffossilfuels.

Theshifthasresultedinasurgeindemandforelectricautomobiles,withthecostof

electricvehiclesbecomingmoreaffordableforabroaderrangeofconsumers.

Ourquestion:Istheeraofgas-poweredautomobilescomingtoanend?

Pro:Ithinktheeraofgas-poweredautomobilesiscomingtoanend.

Con:Idon’tthinktheeraofgas-poweredautomobilesiscomingtoanend.

No.3

Background:Choosingcollegemajorsiscriticaltostudents.Mostofthemaremore

likelytofollowtheirpassionorinterestswhendecidingontheirmajorwhiletheir

parentsmayurgethemtoselecttheirmajorbasedonjobprospectsorincome

potential.

Ourquestion:Shouldstudentschoosetheircollegemajorbasedonsalarylevelsor

theirownpersonalinterests?

Pro:Studentsshouldchoosetheircollegemajorbasedontheirownpersonal

interests.

Con:Studentsshouldchoosetheircollegemajorbasedonsalarylevels.

No.4

Background:Aroundtheworldtherearegrowinginterestsincreatingsustainable

citieswheremostpeople’sdailyneedscanbemetwithinashortwalkorcycle.This

typeofcommunity,whichhasgainedgreatpopularitythesedays,iscalled20-minute

community,withitsfocusonlivingwithina20-minuteradiusofone'shome.

Ourquestion:Shouldwebuild20-minutecommunitiesinChina?

Pro:Ithinkweshouldbuild20-minutecommunitiesinChina.

Con:Idon’tthinkweshouldbuild20-minutecommunitiesinChina.

No.5

Background:Bluefoodsarefoodsproducedfromtheocean,lakesandrivers.They

playanessentialroleinachievingfoodsecurity,endingmalnutritionandbuilding

healthy,nature-positiveandresilientworldfoodsystems.However,theyareoften

neglectedinfoodsystemdiscussions.

Ourquestion:Doyouthinkbluefoodsareareliablefoodsourceforhumanbeings?

Pro:Ithinkbluefoodsareareliablefoodsourceforhumanbeings.

Con:Idon’tthinkbluefoodsareareliablefoodsourceforhumanbeings.

No.6

Background:DecentworkisdefinedbytheInternationalLaborOrganization(ILO)

asproductiveworkforwomenandmeninconditionsoffreedom,equity,securityand

humandignity.Officeworkisusuallyconsideredasdecentworkwithhighsocial

esteemwhilephysicalworkisgenerallyviewedjustastheopposite.

Ourquestion:Doyouthinkphysicalworkisdecent?

Pro:Ithinkphysicalworkisdecent.

Con:Idon’tthinkphysicalworkisdecent.

No.7

Background:TheOECD(OrganizationforEconomicCooperationandDevelopment)

hasestimatedthat14%ofjobsareathighriskofautomation.Thedrastic

advancementintechnologyhasposedasignificantchallengetotraditional

employmentpatterns,asmachinesarereadilyreplacinglowerskilledworkersina

rangeofindustries.

Ourquestion:Willautomationcausemassunemployment?

Pro:Ithinkautomationwillcausemassunemployment.

Con:Idon’tthinkautomationwillcausehighunemployment.

No.8

Background:Thebigfish/smallfishanalogyiscommonineveryindustry.Youmay

beatopperformerinyourfieldandhavejustbeenofferedajobatoneofthe

country’stopthreefirms.Thepayandotherbenefitsarehuge.Youalsohaveanother

offerfromasmallerfirmwithhugegrowthpotential.Thisofferisatoppositionthat

isinteresting,dynamicbutchallenging.Thesalaryisaverage,morethanwhatyouare

currentlyearning,butlowerthanthatofth