歐尚新星店二期總包工程第一輪授標(biāo)推薦報告

AuchanNingboXinxingRoadStoreProject(Phase歐尚寧波店二期工TenderEvaluation General總承包工The:NingboImmochanRealEstateCo.,業(yè)主：寧波置PM:ShanghaiUManConstructionProjectManagementCo.,項目管理 裕滿建筑工程管

Date:January.7th,日期：201317歐尚寧波店二期工程總承包授標(biāo)推薦報告(第一輪TenderEvaluationand mendationReportOfGeneralContractingForAuchanNingboXinxingRoadStoreProject(PhaseNingboImmochanRealEstateCo.,寧波置業(yè)AuchanHypermarketNingboXinxingRoadStoreisasupermarketinvestedbyNingboImmochanRealEstateCo..TheprojectlandlocatedatthecrossofHuanChengWestRoadandXinxingRoadinNingbo.Thelandareais67,685m2.Thefoundationistubularpilefoundation.Thetotalbuildingareaisabout179,589m2.Thewholeprojectisdividedintotwophases.Thebuild-upareaforthefirstphaseisabout52,135m2,including34,135m2abovegroundandthebasementisabout18,000m2.Andthesecondphaseisabout127,724.36m2,including74,166.74m2abovegroundandthebasementisabout53,557.61m2.ThebasementflooronPhaseⅡisdesignedforparkinggarageandmachineroom.1F、2Fisdesignedforsmallshopsandanchorstores.2Fisdesignedforsupermarketsandfreshareas.Thepartof3F、4Fiscatering.ThescopeofthisTenderistheGeneralContractorworksinSecondPhase.Referringtoconstructiondrawingsandrelevanttendering s.TheTenderofPiling&retainingandprotectingforfoundationexcavationWorksisCBTGC.2012December19,Umanmanagementbidforfamiliesraisethequestionthe2012年12月19日，管理公司對各家投標(biāo)疑問進(jìn)行了回復(fù)TheadditionaltendersanddrawingswerereleasedonDec.25thof2012andopenedinwitnessbyAuchan’sprojectmanageratAuchanheadquarterconferenceroomonDec.27ndof2012.2012年12月25日收到上述五家投標(biāo)單位返回的第一輪投標(biāo)文件并于12月27日在歐尚項目經(jīng)理的下在歐尚總部會議室進(jìn)行開標(biāo)；UManorganizedthetenderevaluationandprovidesthetenderevaluationreportbaseonallthefirstcommercial/technicaltendersandtheinterviewresultsonJan.7th2013.201317二商務(wù)標(biāo)分析commercialtender歐尚寧波店二期工程總承包工程的第一輪投標(biāo)報價匯總詳見下表Thetenderquotationsarecollectedasthefollowing總承包單位投標(biāo)報價一覽 單位：ListoftheGeneral unitprice:項中八揚州建江蘇建南通新項中八揚州建江蘇建南通新000000000總包、配費00000000 Fromtheabovecanbeseeninthesummary:2012December25,backtostandard,thetenderofferthereexistsconsiderablegap,thequotationfromlowtohighasfollows:JiangsuConstuction<CBTGC<YangzhouConstruction<NanjingⅧ<Xinhua,thereintothebiggestgapbetweenhighestpriceandlowestpricewasabout38millions.AccordingtothebidderstoprovidedetailedysisoftiescanseethatthehighestofferinNTXHbuilt,NJBJsecond,thatenterprisesinNingbotechnicallevelandmanagementlevelofhighcost,thistwounitPriceisthebudgetoftheprojectinternalcontrol;andCBTG’s.priceisrelativelyreasonable.從上面匯總表中可以看出：2012年12月25日的回標(biāo)中，各投標(biāo)單位的報價存在不小差距，其報價從低到高依次為：江蘇建工<中技集團(tuán)<揚州建工<八建<南通新華，最高報價與最低報價之間的差距約達(dá)3800萬。根據(jù)對各投標(biāo)人提供的詳細(xì)工程量進(jìn)行分析可以得Therecord,scoringandevaluationofthe歐尚寧波店二期總承包工程第一輪報價打分投標(biāo)單投標(biāo)----Accordingtotheysisofallcommercials,thereasonablerankingofthethreetenderersshouldbe:1.Yangzhou2.CBTGC;3.JiangsuConstuction；4.Nanjing從商務(wù)標(biāo)分析來看，五家投標(biāo)單位比較合理的順序依次是：揚州建工>中技>江蘇建工>八建>南通新華三、技術(shù)標(biāo)分析technicalproposalThetenderforaturnkeybiddingphaseⅡoftheproject,theownersareverytightconstructionschedule,technicalstandardshavetheirownadvantagesanddisadvantagesofeach,buttheybasicallymeettheconstructionrequirements,CBTGC’stechnicalprogramofexpressioninthewholeunittobeslightlybetterthantheother,CBTGC’stechnicalstandardfromtheproject'sdifficultiesandthekeyfeaturesoftheprojectdescriptionandassumptions,thequalityassurancesystemisalsoverysound,anddeepfoundationofthemaintenanceprogramandtheprocessdescribedindetail.CCIDandHACEhaveanumberofrelativelysimpletechnicalsolutionisnotasgoodasotherunits本次招標(biāo)為二期項目總承包，業(yè)主要求的施工工期非常緊張，各家的技術(shù)標(biāo)各有優(yōu)劣，但都基本符合施工要求，從技術(shù)方案來看，中技的技術(shù)方案在整體表達(dá)方面要稍優(yōu)于南通新華、八建、揚州建工、江蘇建工，其技技術(shù)標(biāo)從項目的難點和工程的特點進(jìn)行了重點描述和設(shè)想，質(zhì)量保證體系也非常健全，并工藝有詳細(xì)的說明，南通新華、八建、揚州建工、江蘇建工的技術(shù)方案比較簡單一些，針對性則不如中技；Accordingtotheysisofall s,thereasonablerankingofthefivetenderersshouldbe:1.CBTGC;2.NanjingⅧ;NantongXinhua;4.JiangsuConstruction.5.Yangzhou五家投標(biāo)單位的技術(shù)標(biāo)比較合理的順序依次是中 八建>南通新華>江蘇建工>揚州建工Thesubmissionsandinterviewresultsareas南通新Methodstatement:basicallypractical;buttherearesomeshortageintheconstructionlayoutnandtemporaryfacilitiesSchedule:basicallysatisfy,butwithoutthedetailedandreasonablegeneralOrganizationchart:reasonableorganizationKeystaffofmanagement:projectmanagerand nelpresent,Projectmanager'sexperiencewithsimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis中 Methodstatement:goodnecessarypertinence;reasonableorganizationandDeepFoundationprocedureSchedule:detailedandreasonableenough,takeconsiderationofconstructiontimeforAuchan’sSub-generalcontractorandtheotherunites,takeconsiderationofcooperationbetweensiteworkand ernmentwork;施工進(jìn)度計劃：詳細(xì)且合理，考慮了與歐尚分包及其它單位進(jìn)場配合問題，考慮了現(xiàn)場和的協(xié)調(diào)Organizationchart:reasonableorganizationKeystaffofmanagement:projectmanagerand nelpresent,Projectmanager'sexperiencewithsimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis3八建NanjingMethodstatement:basicallypractical;buttherearesomeshortageintheconstruction nandtemporaryfacilitiesSchedule:basicallysatisfy,butwithoutthedetailedandreasonablegeneralOrganizationchart:reasonableorganizationchart;Keystaffofmanagement:projectmanagerand nelpresent,Projectmanager'sexperiencewithsimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemisIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis揚州建YangzhouConstructionMethodstatementnonecessarypertinence;Schedule:notreasonableenough,takenoconsiderationofconstructiontimeforAuchan’sSub-generalcontractorandthearoundsituationonsiteOrganizationchart:reasonableorganizationKeystaffofmanagement:allpresentandtheprojectmanager,LesssimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemiscompleteIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis江蘇建工JiangsuMethodstatement:basicallypractical;buttherearesomeshortageintheconstructionlayoutnandtemporaryfacilitiesSchedule:basicallysatisfy,butwithoutthedetailedandreasonablegeneralOrganizationchart:reasonableorganizationchart;Keystaffofmanagement:allpresentandtheprojectmanager,LesssimilarIntegratedqualitycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemiscompleteIntegratedsafetycontrolsystem:theguaranteesystemis四、竟標(biāo)打Basedon ysisresultsofcommercialandtechnicalsubmission,thetwoturn sweremarkedas結(jié)合商務(wù)標(biāo)和技術(shù)標(biāo)的分析結(jié)果，對各投標(biāo)單位的兩輪投標(biāo)文件進(jìn)行綜合打分，其結(jié)果如下分評分標(biāo)分各參與競標(biāo)單位打分江蘇建八南通新?lián)P州建中技FormatandLogotechnical工程量采用EXCEL格式TheoveralloftechnicalTherationalityoftechnicalnTheintegralitytechnicalThepertinencetechnicalTherationalityoftechnicalmeasureTherationalityofdisposalnTemporarypowerTemporarywaterRationalityofconstructionnThematerialon-siteTheguaranteemeasureforprojectscheduleTheguaranteemeasureforconstructionTheguaranteemeasureforconstructingsafetyandcivilizationTheenvironmentprotectionmeasureTheequipmentnforconstructionand1.設(shè)備；2.人材機(jī)單價Labor隊成員Organization