中美清潔能源產業(yè)爭端的解決路徑――中美風能設備補貼爭端案的思考

1、 W o r d E c o n o m y S tu d y i N o.7 , 2011 (Ser a N o.2 09 il A n In t r at on a E con o而 e R e村ew f r P ri t E q u t In vestm en t a d L B O s e n i i o va e l y n a g i Y n M n g qiu (29 Pr vat equ i and i L B O s a i e y t ts e r one o t e m ost l f h ively a ti ti of i t n at l eapit m arket

2、 in t e last 20 years. T h i c vi es n er iona l a s h s stu d y f eu se s o n L B O s o r g in a te d b y p r v a e e q u ity f n d s f m th e v ie w o f e e o n o m ie s , a d so m e r la te d issu e s w ill b e m e n tio n e d . o i i t u o r n e T h e T h r e sh o ld of E x cha n ge R a te F u e

3、t a t o n o n o u r I m P o r l u i t an d E x Po r t J勿n g u y 石月 S u g ua n 9 h g a g Y n h S en到 g (3 擔n 6 P re v io u s res e re h e s a b o u t th e r la io n sh ip b e t e e n ex e h an g e ra e a n d tr d e b a a n e e a re a w a y s b a e d o n lin e a m o d e ls , b u t th e e t w t a l l s

4、 r e r la to n sh ip m a y b e n o l in ea r u n d e r d if r n t e x e h a n g e r te r n ge s a d d 政 r n t e x e h a g i e f e a a n e n e t a r e e h a n g e s . T h is p a p e r stu d y s th e e r lat ionsh i bet een exehan ge r te f uetuat p w a l ion and our expor & i por b ased on t r sh

5、ol p an el m odel usi t m t he d ng t e year y data f m h l o r 19 85 t 20 08 of C h i a. 17 m ain t e par ners. T e result ar as f l s : ( 1 M arsh a l一 r er eond i on alw ays holds u nder a o n 5 rad t h s e o low l 反n ti l the di rent , xeha g e r t ran羅s , and t ese 15 no t e shol ef et. ( 2 M a

6、rsha 一 r er eond i on holds w i exehan ge r t e f n a e h hr d f e l L n e ti th a e a p p re e ia tin g o v er 1 1 . 7 8 % , h ow e v e r , M a rs h 欲l一 r e r eo n d itio n d o e s n o t h old u n d er o th e r e o n d itio n s . e L n T h e V 碰 山t D i y seu ssi on on Int re t R ate P U ci bet een

7、C h in a an d U .5 . e s O s e w 叉 C u n 砰u 勿h A s a n im p o r a t too l f r m o n e t娜 tn o th e le v e l o f in l f 3 0 ye a s r f O p o lie y im P lie a tio n s , in te r s t ra te h a s 腳 a t in e l f Sh o Z i i (43 a h qn u e n e e o n n a tio n a e eo n o m y . H ow e v e r , w h at l e o n e

8、 lu sio n . W ith th e h e lp o a m o st f l by m eans o f u e n e e th e in ter s t r te a f狡e tin g th e m a e r 一 o n om ie re 邵 la tio n h a sn , t a u n if r e a o ee o m ie e m P ir e a d a a , th is a r iele d is e u ss e s th e in t r s ra i l t t e e t t e n a io n a e e o n o t l m s, i呷 a

9、 t on th e n a tio n a e eo n o 卿 c l posi ive ana y si t l s. W e f n d that C hina, 5 i e st rate poli i . f l va i i y , w h i e inter st r e p oli i t e U n i i nter ey sn t u ly l d t l e t a ey n h ted St ates plays a f lly v alid ity . M e a n w h ile , a n a a y sis o f w h a t e a u se s in

10、 te r st r te s . d if re n t v a id itie s 15 e xa m in e d . F in a lly , d r u n l e a e f l w a in g o n th e ex p e r e n e e o f th e A m e r e a n in te re st r te p o lie y im p le m e n tatio n , w e of r p rop o sa ls o n h o w to in er a se th e v a lid ity o f in te r st ra te i i a e f

11、e e p o lie y in C h in a . A n A n a ly sis o n t e W T O h D is P u t e C a s e o n W in d P O e w r S u b sid y M e a -u r es b e tw e e n C h in a a d U . 5 . n S hen D a on y g o g G n e n er y g a ha 9 B i u (4 in e lu d in g th e h T er e e o u ld b e so m e e o n ie ts b etw e e n C h in a a

12、 n d t e U n ite d S ta te s o v e r t e d e ve lo p m e n t o f t e e le a l f h h h n w in d p o w e r . T is p a p e w ill stu d y o n th e re e e n t 琪, l,0 h D is p u te e a se b e t e e n C h in a an d th e U n ite d S ta te s ov e r C h in a , 5 su b sid y w m e a su re s f r th e d e v e lo

13、p m e n t o f its w in d p o w e r in d u st叮. o D o se T e c n o o g h l y N o n 一 o n lin a n t C o u n tr e s S e t n g u P T e c n c a d i i h i i B ar i er s M a e S e n e :A n O P n T w o C o u n t e k s e i r s M o e d l Zh o C unm i a h ng B a s e d o n th e f cl th a t C h in a , 5 in te r

14、a tio n a a n l tr d e a e tiv itie s h a v e b e e n : f r n g th e te e h n ie 習 b a 示 er a su e i s h C en 月 o (54 乞 se t u p b y te h n ie a c l su p e r o r ty e o u :一 e s f 邵 e n tly , a n d w ith th e e sta b lish m e n t of a n o P e n m o d e l i i tr i e r br ar o d th is p a p er v o in

15、te d o u t th a t i te e h n ie a g P 15 n ot f l a y l i i f th o se e o u n tr e s th a t , e v e n if th e y a e , o t d o m in an t in te e h n o lo g , ea n a so b r n g b e n e ts to th e n a tio n a w e i r d u e to th e i r l a f e / s tr et s u l長le e e f e t 0 in te e h n ie a l b a l ,le

16、r . T h e r f r , in th e e a se th a i e o e t l s e C h in a 15 n o t d o m in a n r in te eh n o lo g y , w e sh ou ld also respon d t t eh a l ges a e tiv elv . W ith o u t v io la tin g th e p r v is io n s o o he l en o f b y u sin g r a so n ab le te e h n o lo 郡 re str e tion s . e i r f e e tr d e r le s a n d W fl,O a u w e e a n also in e r a s e o u r w e lf re e a N ew Tr nds o e f I n t rn a e i t on a l T r de P a r o te c t o n M e i s a u r e s in th e C o n tex t o f E e o n o 而 e R e e o v e r y n a d